Reviews for Brooklyn Pizza in Tallahassee, FL
I wish I could select 0 stars. I ordered a calzone. After I started eating it, I discovered a roach crawling in the box. I was... mortified and disgusted. Of course this can happen anywhere but it happened here. Never again. Read more
Clean pleasant employees, and the best Calzone I have inhaled in a while. Canned and bottled sodas available. Good job Brooklyn... Pizza! Read more
Awesome place! Always knew it was in town but never considered it. Finally tried it out a few weeks ago and it's great! I've... been back 5 times! They even have dine-in options. The New York style pizza, of course, is wonderful. It's a must to get Pestosauce on whatever toppings! Try it! But it's the wings that hooked me! That Hot Garlic Parm hits EVERY time! Would recommendthis place to anyone. Read more
Our calzones were identical orders, but the consistency wasn't there. Barely any ricotta inside and I counted about 5 mushrooms,... which were an extra cost. I'll stay away from this place and get a real calzone for less. The marinara that came with it tasteslike crushed tomatoes from a can. Read more
I don?t usually do reviews but seriously? Over $9 for a sub that came with 5 strips of fake chewy chicken.. I added peppers and... onions and they were bigger than the meat. Another $10 for a pizza that should be labeled a personal. These two came to over $35for delivery. This was horrible. Read more
BEST PIZZA IN TALLY! We come once a week for the lunch special. Owner is super nice and really chill environment.
This place was delish!! The pizza dough was fresh, the ???? was also good, as the breadsticks and calzone. Huge helpings!... Definitely worth it. Read more
The pizza was very thin as well as the crust. It was stale cold and the crust was hard. I lived in NY, and this was definitely... not Brooklyn pizza. Horrible. Deserves no stars. They also took about an hour to deliver it. Read more