Reviews for Pump Pizza Pub in Syracuse, NY
Everyone needs an Anne if their life! Went tonight and she was busy but always smiling and super efficient. We ordered the boom... boom shrimp which was sooo spicy and delicious and the pepperoni deep dish. I'm sooo used to deep dish pizzas that are soggy onthe bottom this was crispy and soooo good! Thank you Anne we will be back! Read more
Got take out once and dined with a group of 16 here last night. Thought the food was great both times. Among my favorites were... the Scampi deep dish, Pepperoni Deep Dish, and meatballs. The chicken francaise is also tasty. Our whole crew tried tons ofother dishes and all enjoyed. The deep dish crust is very good. I'm no deep dish expert but this crust was sturdy andbuttery--almost like a cross between pastry and pizza dough. I'm a NYC slice kinda girl but I really do love the deep dishesI've had here. I recommend you go with friends and order a couple pizzas and apps/entrees to share. The food lends it's selfwell to enjoying family style. The place has a nice atmosphere--even a bit cozy since they have a fireplace. (I think it was gasor faux but still). Met the owner and he was a nice guy. Seemed like a slim staff but the place was full at one point and wedidn't face service issues other than a slightly long wait at the bar. If you have a large party, calling to preorder your foodmay be a good idea. Read more
Fun pub atmosphere with nice top-shelf liquors and 12+ beers on tap. But---come for the food!! The pizza is outstanding, both... the NY Style which is simply perfection, and the Chicago style, which is so perfectly spot-on, you would think you were on theNorth Side of Chicago! Perfect butter crust, there is none like it in the entire area. The pasta dishes, burgers, andhand-breaded tenders are some of the best you will find in all of CNY! Read more
A coworker recommended this place for deep dish pizza. Unfortunately, the $27 price tag is not worth the time or money for this... place. Let's start with the dough. The dough is lacking taste. A good Chicago deep dish needs that buttery, layered (it's gotsome layers), flakey crust. Almost croissant like, but denser. This crust is too dense and not buttery enough. Moving onto thesauce, the sauce is lacking depth. It's got the basic flavor, but it feels like it's missing something. More oregano, moregarlic. Moving onto the cheese, it doesn't feel like it's a higher quality cheese for what you pay for an entire pizza. Weended up throwing the last 2-3 slices away out of the 6. Overall, the Detroit motor city pizza company that makes frozen pizzafor $7 is better than this. Read more
There is alot of hype about this joint. I may have ordered bad. I ordered the vegetable deep dish. The crust was good but the... sauce was lacking. The crust wasn't golden brown. It was ok like good airport pizza. But nothing to write home about. I will trythe seafood scampi next time. Read more
Went here tonight and got the Buffalo Chicken pizza and it is AMAZING!!!!! The blue cheese is dressing and I love that it's not... the crumbles!. Super friendly staff and owners and amazing food! The caramle Apple Martini is the PERFECT hit of fall withlittle alcohol taste. Definitely recommend anyone looking for amazing food to stop in! Read more
First time here. Pizza crust is even yummy. Sauce is amazing. Good atmosphere. Loved the 80s music too. Wasn't busy at all so I... can't judge on service if it was,but service was good. I like to be asked how the food is,but not totally forgotten so it was ahappy medium. Read more
Excellent food mouth watering for sure, was a beer or mixed drink to wash it down with! I like to come here at least a few times... a week when I can, bartenders & owner are great/ friendly I feel more than comfortable. Gotta try it out trust me... Read more