Reviews for Captain John's Restaurant in Sylvan Beach, NY

My wife and I have gone here many times over the last 26 years and never been disappointed even with the prices. The food has... always been great. Things have certainly changed in the last couple of years. The food last night was not worth the money wepaid. I got the twin lobster ta and steak special, which was $50. The prime rib was not roasted that day by any means, it was areheated piece of meat, I have worked in kitchens before and know dry reheated prime rib when I see it. I also order a margaritain which the waitress said was a two for one special. I guess the special was you get to wonder why there was no tequila in yourdrink, I did not order a non alcoholic version. My wife also felt her drink had little to no alcohol. I ordered a bisque andsalad to go with my meal. They were both brought bout at the same time and I was barely done eating my cup of bisque and ourentrees were being placed in front of us. The waitress then had to apologize for the food coming out so quick.The waitress wasvery friendly, but they sent her on break before we were done eating and left others to clean up and give us our check, that issomething you just don't do in the business. Sad to say it will be a long time before we go back when they charge premium pricesfor sub par meals at this point. Read more

My husband and I had our anniversary dinner here. Food was outstanding. Didn't go with their everyday $24.99 as we saw what was... being brought to other tables, theirs looked thin. We ordered the mate prime rib and king's cut and they were perfectly sizedand cooked for the price. We had this lobster appetizer sorry can't remember the name of it but it was very tasty and reallobster with a cucumber Wassabi sauce. No picture of appetizer. I was completely in the moment. The drinks we ordered were verygood as well. Except the bloody Mary had ice shaving instead of chunks of ice. Was like a slushy bloody Mary. Weird. Also gave 4stars cause I felt we were rushed. Dinner came 4 minutes after our appetizers. Lessoned learned don't order meal till appetizerscome out. We will go back definitely for the prime rib. Read more

First of all as promised to our favorite bar tender Andy, this restaurant is unmatched in the sylvan beach area! The environment... is like something out of the Bahamas . Andy is always a very quick bar tender and the servers are great too! He remembers usevery year we go for our wood pallets ! The food is very fresh and the menu is unique! As an expert level reviewer I wouldhighly recommend this spot for everyone!! Read more

The food and atmosphere were fantastic!! The service was friendly and energetic. The drinks were delicious. Highly recommend... stopping in and enjoying the experience!! Read more

This place has been a favorite of mine since I was a child! I live in Chicago now but I make sure I visit Captain John's... everytime I'm home. AMAZING food at great prices. Super fun atmosphere and friendly staff! Read more

The ambience and decor are unique. During the years they have served great food for tourists and locals. Unfortunately our... experience wasn't so good this time. As other reviews mentioned, the quality of the food is not great but the prices are on theexpensive side. We were also very disappointed with the cocktails. The good thing the staff is great. Always smiling andfriendly. We are not going back again at least for a while. Read more

Food was very good. Steak and prime rib were cooked perfectly. The dessert was delicious!Only issue was with dining room space.... The isle space was so cramped that the staff as on top of each other trying to get around the dining room. There was no room formore than one person going one way. Read more

Neat place, awesome vibe, food was ok, not the best but definitely not the worst. Prices are ridiculously high, but its the... only game in a tourist town. Was nice but without a good deal and awesome food, for my money I wouldn't make a second trip. Ileft feeling ripped off and was definitely walking funny from the reaming they gave my wallet. Read more