Reviews for Holland American Bakery in Sussex, NJ
Had wanted to go here for years. Quaint shop. However the items I purchased did not seem fresh and the one cookie, lindsar... tart, tasted as if the lard used was old, rancid. Read more
I?m Dutch on my dads side and I feel like a proper Dutch girl in this bakery. There?s an almond paste bread that I forgot the... name of but is soooooo good. The danishes are great, the cronuts and anything almond flavor. You go in there and you smell thebaked goods. Also their breakfast sandwiches ???? are great. Tasty big and great bang for your buck. Looking forward to tryingthe pies during thanksgiving. The also have a whole bunch of pretty Dutch Knick knacks. Even the wooden shoes for decoration. Read more
Old school..they have all of the classics. Cakes and pies made to order, great bread and pastry too! Great breakfast sandwiches... too! On Fridays they have a fish fry food truck too! Great stuff..come check them out ! Read more
Good bakery that used to be great. Just not the same quality that I knew for many years of patronizing this store before I moved... out of state a few years ago. We were in for a wedding and stopped for an almond pastry. Very little paste in this cake. Tastybut now average compared to what it used to be. Too bad. Read more
The doughnuts at this place are really good. Blueberry Jelly filled was my favorite thus far. The Apple fritters were tasty... too Had an egg sandwich bread was outstanding but the egg was burnt. I'd definitely come back for the baked goods Read more
Very disappointed about this Bakery. We drove 1.5 hours specially for this Bakery and bought over $85 dollars products. The... bread went bad in like 2 days. Mold all over it! We also saw mold on the cheeses that we saw in the counter (and btw I didreally saw mold on your cheeses, please don't tell me that it was something that was "overlooked" I'm not stupid)! Also yourother products are bad quality! We received damage products and the bread was like 2 days old and already had fungus so thatstill didn't explain why it had fungus, even if you don't use preservatives! We also bought "Jan Hagel Cookies", I asked thegirl behind the counter if they were soft and she told us it will get hard in a few days, this is also such a lie, the cookiesare still soft (why would you lie to your customers??) Very disappointed, i wouldn't recommend this bakery to anyone!!! Read more
Simply stated... absolutely THE BEST bakery items you will ever taste! Have been coming here for decades, and the service and... quality is consistently EXCELLENT! Cakes, to cookies to treats, you will find your perfect bakery item here. Stop buyingoccasion cakes from the supermarket. You cannot top the home made quality and taste found in Holland American Bakery items.Prices are very reasonable. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! Read more
Treat yourself to a trip to Europe without boarding an airplane! Nice people serving nice baked goods. Try their bagels, then be... prepared for a trip to Brooklyn in the 50's. This place is the real deal. Read more