Reviews for New York New York Greek Restaurant in Surrey, BC

Every time I visit BC, I must come here to ingest their most flavourful and fall off the bone roast lamb. I'll make a bold... statement and say if this restaurant was in Greektown, Toronto.. I would go there 90% of the time. Fight me. They also havetheir potatoes done perfectly with the right amount of sourness *chef's kiss*. Even the rice packs a flavourful punch. The saladalways tastes super fresh. I leave satisfied every single time. Do not bother cheating with other Greek restaurants in the citybecause they are less of a drive... you will end up severely disappointed. This place is worth the gas. There is only one thingI wish this place had... Gyros. Read more

Good food. Family style place. Had the roast lamb. Good portion, tender meat.

Came here for dinner with several family members. The meals and service was great. The 18% gratuity understable as there were 8... of us. What absolutely annoyed me and will make me not come back again was a $4 plate sharing fee. What the hell is a sharingfee. My daughter's wanted to share a plate instead of getting their own meals so we were dinged $4 for sharing a plate. Youwould think the owners would be appreciative of people coming in and spending money in person versus ordering off of a fooddelivery service. Our meal was almost $300 but the owners could not live without a $4 fee. Next time my family and I will spendour money elsewhere. What a fantastic way to sour a great evening. Read more

The New York New York restaurant that we have always loved is no more. I had been going here since I was 15 years old and I am... now 34. It's always been a comfort food spot just knowing that you're going to get delicious food with generous portions.Unfortunately it appears its changed ownership and new recipes are being used. I haven't had bad food in a while, and as much asit pains me to say this was just bad food. I could look past the smaller portions - but the lack of flavour is tough to swallow(literally). No more garlic butter, no more delicious combinations of savory goodness. Just bland, stale textured food. Bummedbecause we very rarely treat ourselves for takeout and this was a big time disappointment. I feel its unethical to operateunder the same name, but have nothing similar to what many have been used to for over a decade. 2 stars because the girl at thefront was friendly and gorgeous. Hope the new owners can get their hands on the previous recipes! Read more

Great Greek place in Surrey! The roast lamb was soft, tender and tasted amazing. The only con is that the portion of the rice is... pretty small compared to other Greek restaurants I've been to in the Lower Mainland. The restaurant was nice and clean and notvery busy when we went. Also, everything else tasted great including the calamari appetizer. Read more

Great environment and service was great and attentive. The portions were also plentiful and everything came out from the kitchen... really fast. Just wished the pita was toasted and taziki was lacking flavor. The lamb main I ordered was really soft, but thechicken dish was great. I would recommend this place to others. Read more

Probably one of the best Greek food restaurants in Surrey. The portions are very good, tried the chicken parmigiana and was very... satisfied. The staff are lovely. I like the vibe of this restaurant, it felt cozy. Will be paying another visit sometime. Read more

First time coming here and we were not disappointed. My Chicken Parmigiano was great along with the Purple New York cocktail.... Absolutely would recommend this place and next time will try out other cocktails which looked amazing ???? Read more