Reviews for Rosati's Pizza in Sullivan, IL
This is really the only place you can get a Chicago style pizza within 50 miles of Sullivan, and it's actually comparable to... other Chicago pizza joints. Even so, their Monster pizza is the real stunner. I'm pretty sure it's loaded with everything theyhave in the kitchen yet somehow the crust doesn't turn out all doughy. Read more
They need to let you have real plates and have real silverware while dining in. The waitress was excellent
We are originally from Chicago and now live in Lancaster PA. Our in-laws live in a small town nearby. The whole family misses... Chicago thin crust big time. This Rosati's gave us everything we miss. Thanks for being in a small town we appreciate it. Read more
I've always enjoyed the food and service in the past. However, recently it has taken a turn in the wrong direction. First, the... service this last time I went was less than adequate. The waitress was in a rush to get our order when there was hardly a soulin the place. She seemed more interested in talking with the men across the room which left me to refill my own drink at thefountain by the bar. I had ordered an Italian beef (normally one of the best sandwiches on the menu but I'll get to that in amoment) with fries and a side salad. I never received the fries that we inturn paid for. Just terrible service. Now for theItalian beef. The sandwich is usually pretty good as I stated, but this time it was terribly salty. So salty the taste of saltwas in my mouth for the rest of the day even after I had tried to wash it out. This is probably why I had drink so much soda, tohelp wash away the salt. To think of it now, it's probably a good thing I didn't receive the fries because those may have beentwice as salty. The burger my father ordered was still raw in the center and loaded with way too many onions. He had to pick offthe onions and I honestly don't know how he ate what he did. In closing, I will not be returning due to poor service, poorlyprepared food, and the fact we were charged for food that we never received. This was a very, very disappointing visit and I donot suggest any one eating there. Read more
Honestly, the pizza is always good and I love their Italian dressing for their salads. We normally wait for at least 20 minutes... to get our check and pay to leave though, and that is just a bit much. Especially when someone else might need our table. ButI also know everyone is short on staff now and that adds to this type of issues. Just keep trying and making great pizzas Read more
Great pizza!! It's definitely worth the 40 mile round trip!! Try the Chicago style pizza!! Yummy ????????
Very very good. 1st time visit. We have always wanted to try it and I'm glad we did. Will definitely be back.
Great food, owner even helped me out when I was at a low point.