Reviews for Carletto Pizza & Pasta in Sudlersville, MD
Our thin crust pizza was good. We ordered mushroom garlic toppings it was satisfying. I wanted to taste the pasta and tried the... basic type..red sauce meatballs... It's fresh tasting but pasta is too soft / done for my prefference. I did not ask if it canbe aldente though so not sure if possible. Our waitstaff is cheery and delightful. It was a great impulse last minute findspot. Read more
If you want a taste of visiting an Italian family for dinner, stop in Carletto. The atmosphere is perfect . You can dine in or... take out the staff and owner Michelle are always amazing and accommodating. We Will continue to go back. Read more
Great pizza! Tasty sauce and crisp crust. excellent cheese steak.
Carlettos is more then a pizza shop, i come here and am always welcomed with a smile and a good conversation especially if... Michelle is there! This place has always made me feel at home along with the having best pizza around. Thank you guys forstaying in business and keeping our town fed. I appreciate you all! Best prices around aswell! Read more
Tried Carletto for the first time tonight, and everything was outstanding! Mozzarella Caprese was perfect. My husband had a... gorgeous salad with grilled shrimp, and we are certain the dressing is homemade. Great service, cute atmosphere. Justdelightful. We will definitely be back. Read more
A little off the beaten path on our way to a weekend in St Michael?s from the suburbs of Philadelphia. Didn?t look like much... from the outside however once inside we were greeted by a very friendly server. She made sure we were waited on promptly andmade great recommendations. Everything was delicious. Had a speciality thin crust pizza, a side of pasta and garlic knots. Wish it wasn?t 90 min from home but we may find ourselves taking a day trip this fall. Read more
This is a ?preview? review because I only have one small point of reference: Stopped w the motorcycles for some water, tea &... snack on our way home from the ocean. Had no idea it was a cafe; thought it was a convenience store. Sat & had the meatball?side? as a snack. O.M.G. As good as I?ve had on Arthur Ave in the Bronx or Little Italy in Manhattan. REAL meatballs & gravy.If the rest of the menu is this good?. Only challenge is that it?s 90 minutes from home. I will definitely be back for more. Read more
I loved my experience here! The owner was the kindest most beautiful woman inside and out. She went above and beyond to serve me... and make me feel welcome. Great food too! Read more