Reviews for Kitty O'Reillys Irish Pub in Sturgeon Bay, WI
Good experience and food. Indoor and outdoor seating available. There was a wait outdoors so we had to sit inside. Looks like... they are making an addition in the back for an outdoor space. A variety of different food options, lobster mac and cheese, bbqpulled pork mac and cheese, burgers, Maui Maui tacos, etc. Portions are big, but food was not as good as I had hoped. Read more
Wonderful indoor outdoor setup. Staff was great, food was great, drinks were great. Do not underestimate their portion sizes,... food or drink. The dragon eggs don't actually have any eggs, it's just chicken and cream cheese mix in a jalapeño shell, it'sactually spicy ????. The bbq sauce used on the rack of ribs is more tangy than sweet. The cocktails were heavy, they will messyou up. There's also a cat that wanders around, doesn't seem to be bothered at all by the people. Lots of on-site parking. Atminside. Read more
So much food. Extensive drink & food menu. Great service. Wonderful decor indoors and outdoors. Reasonable prices. I had Mermaid... Water (yum), cheese curds (double yum), Irish Stew (OMG). Husband had ridiculously huge Cobb Salad. Read more
Food was mediocre. Very disappointed, my salad was a pile of spinach with five pieces of shrimp. I had to set aside all the... extra spinach on another plate. My girlfriend ordered the pulled pork Mac and cheese and it so fatty and dry. She had to ask totake it back to the kitchen and ordered the Buffalo Mac and cheese instead. Once again, it was a disappointment. Way overpricedfor its quality of food. Read more
Excellent place for a quick drink and snack in the middle of the day when we stopped in. It has that great small town feel, but... it is still welcoming to outsiders. We just got brandy old fashions and the tots covered in cheese and bacon. The drinks werepoured real well and the "nachos tots" (I forget the actual name) were cooked beautifully. No complaints on any aspect of thisbar and I highly recommend it to anyone. Read more
Went here for lunch with my family and we had a great time !! The atmosphere and decor was very inviting. We sat in a nice big... booth and the service was phenomenal. They were extremely busy and it was great to see the teamwork attitude as all theemployees were rushing around making sure all customer's were happy. I ordered a bloody Mary and it was absolutely delicious !!! Prices were reasonable and the food was excellent !!! Definitely planning to stop again on our next adventure to Door County. Read more
Very busy on a Friday evening around 5:30 but we were able to get the last table for 6. The Prickly Pear margarita was good but... I wouldn?t pay $12 for it again. Very sweet and not very strong. The Kitty Cobb salad was delicious and huge portion. Theslow-cooked corned beef on top was a nice twist on a classic Cobb. Fine service. The outdoor patio looked really nice and hadbig overhead heaters. Read more
Our first time to kitty O'Reillys and it was quite mediocre. The reviews are so good, we were very excited then left... underwhelmed. Mimosas are a great deal on Sunday and tasty. Husband's chicken was good but pretty average. My bbq mac was sobland, like no flavor...I ordered extra bbq sauce which helped a little. Service was slow for how empty the place was, friendlythough. We would not return if back in the area. Read more