Reviews for Bennys in Stroudsburg, PA
Don't let the outside appearance fool you this local restaurant is not just a pizza joint, their also servings up some fantastic... pasta dishes. We had 4 different pasta dishes and everyone of them was made to perfection. The Penna al Volka was so flavorfulthat it matched what I've had in many high priced restaurants that charge twice as much. The menu has a good selection of itemsto pick from and the service was outstanding. I wish I lived in the area so I could go back and try every item on the menu. Read more
We were staying with some friends in the Poconos and wanted to try a different place to eat. We came across this pizzeria! It... was a little out of our way but totally worth it!!! The food was delicious! I had the best calzone ever! Portions were big. Icould probably eat 3 more times from it. The manager Norman was so friendly and personable. Can't wait to go there again. Read more
I just wanna say this is probably wanna the best restaurant I been too so far! I took me and family here for dinner one night... and amazing food. They have such nice workers and a wonderful owner. ???? Read more
We were staying at Kalahari Resort in the Poconos and we were looking for a place to get pizza. After searching google maps, we... found Benny's. It was a about a 20 minute drive, and the reviews were good, so we took a chance on driving a little further. Itwas well worth the drive. We ordered a cheese pizza, a taco pizza, fries, and Chicken Marsala. The pizzas had amazing flavor,the fries were good, and the Chicken Marsala was excellent. The pizza crust was great, and the edge of the pizza was just right,not to thick, not thin, and it wasn't dried out like a lot of pizzas. We are from South Central PA, we have plenty of pizzarestaurants in the area, but none of their pizzas compare to Benny's. The staff was very friendly. It's a little off the beatenpath, but worth the drive. The outside of building could use a refresh, which makes you wonder, but the inside is very nice andlooks like it was updated recently. If we travel back to the area, we would dine at Benny's again. We definitely recommendBenny's to anyone that is looking for great food at a good price. Read more
Thanks Bennys for the awesome pizza dough to make our brick oven pizza!
My favorite one is on RT# 715, where owner Luke makes a terrific pizza! Also "Benny's II" his second and newest restaurant @... location RT# 115. Read more
Went here to pick up food to celebrate a family member?s birthday based on the high ratings. Wrong! Had to apologize over and... over again to the family member. No one wanted to save their leftovers so we threw it all away. A waste of time, money, andeffort. Obviously, we?ve had much better ? real Italian pizza masterfully cooked by long standing family run restaurant on theeast coast. Never heard of soggy crust where the toppings literally run off the limp crust. Even the salad lacked flavor as wellas the fully loaded nachos. So hard to find a decent restaurant in the area. Even cooked one of our pizzas wrong and had to goback for a new one. The person who took the order also prepared the pizza. At least he apologized. We?ve only found 2 decentrestaurants, both in Stroudsburg ? a Thai restaurant near Monroe County courthouse, and a Mediterranean restaurant for theirgyros around the corner from the Thai restaurant. Would have been nice to find an authentic family owned pizzeria nearby. Untilthen, east coast will continue to receive our business. Read more
If you're in the mood for a pizza loaded with cheese and a Pizza sauce that's freshly made with just a perfect amount of... sweetness, this is the place. We searched several pizza places in the neighborhood during our trip to the Poconos and cameacross this gem. The crust is chared in all the right places. Thick crust on the Sicilian. I loved it. Read more