Reviews for Pleasant Lake Inn in Stratford, NY
Stumbled upon this place on our way home (to Rochester, NY) after riding mountain bikes all day long at the Wheelerville Trail... System. We were very hungry and this place hit the spot! People recommended the meatloaf and it was hands down the best meatloafwe've ever had! The staff was super friendly and accommodating! Read more
Coming back again!!!! Amazing staff. Great food. Fried haddock was juicy inside and crispy and light on the outside.
Super friendly service. Excellent Lentil Soup and The Schnitzel Strips were killer. Double Fried French fries also excellent.... The Guinness was served in a carafe to split and it was great! Octoberfest menu in place now, everything looked and soundedfantastic. We saw some desserts come out that appeared to be HUGE. The German Chocolate Cake will be on our "to return" forlist! Read more
Pot roast was delicious if a bit pricey. Short staffed but looking to hire. Dessert was excellent and made by a nearby baker.
Delicious chicken sandwich, beer was craft & cold, service was friendly and attentive. Will definitely return for another meal.... Amy runs the front end and is a hoot! Tammy always has a friendly smile and easy going demeanor. I have become a regular, overthe past year. Read more
Once again we had a great meal with no disappointments. Amy, as usual was a great hostess and waitress and the chef did an... amazing job with our dinner!! It's well worth the drive up there. I highly recommend it to all my friends when they want to trya new place. Read more
This is a great find. Super food made to order. Friendly helpful people. Well stocked bar with a good selection of Scotch. A... local clientele year round. Tourists in the summer. Cozy with fireplace great fit in the Adirondacks. Wife and I stop thereoften. Try their pork chop with peppercorn sauce. Dinner salad is always fresh and surprising. Prices reasonable. One of ourfavorite stops. You'll feel at home Read more
The food - huge portions, staff and atmosphere are incredible here. If you haven't been here please go!!