Reviews for Water Street Cafe in Stonington, CT
Best scallops and tuna we have ever eaten. Friendly staff and an overall excellent experience, would definitely suggest to a... friend & make a return visit! Read more
Came here for dinner while on a quick trip to the ocean. Food was phenomenal! Best salmon I've ever had. Drinks were also great,... I got the... twist on an old fashioned? I don't remember what it was called. Excellent though. I will advise that they seemincredibly popular so call in advance to put your name on the list for a table. But I would highly recommend this spot toanyone, great food, drinks and service! If I'm ever back in the area, I will go again! Read more
Food was awesome at good price. The bluefin tuna if it's available was great value. They give you lots of fish for the... price. Dozen oysters were also fresh and tasty. Duck and scallops were also yummy. Duck salad was spot on. Definitely visitagain. Read more
Every thing from the time we entered to the time we left was perfect. The waitress was amazing... the atmosphere was amazing and... the food was perfect... I love it there and we will be back.. Read more
Very good. Oysters available. Group of 10, everyone raved about their meals. Pricey, but worth the treat.
Food and cocktails were fantastic, service was ... leisurely. Probably short staffed, just like everywhere else. Anyway, my... three dinner companions loved the dozen oysters (3 varieties), and we all loved our entrees: Skillet Chicken; Halibut; CrispyDuck; and Duck Breast Salad. The fish and fowl were cooked to perfection; tender and flavorful. The cocktails were tasty and hadquite a bit of alcohol. Overall, well worth the $200 bill (excluding tip). Read more
Fantastic service from the moment you walk in the door to finish. Been here previously and it had been a 3 star rating and was... never really blown out the water until now.. The new chefs were fantastic and explained in detail every entree and catered to myneeds and likings perfectly. Would definitely come back here and/or recommend to all my friends. The quality is unmatched in thearea. The new chefs really know what they?re doing. Read more
We were just having drinks and appetizers. My husband enjoyed one of their house special drinks quite a bit. The escargot pie... was very tasty but extremely small.. barely a couple bites for each of us. The bar service was friendly and pretty efficientuntil we had an issue with what we were seeing on their payment app and she started pointedly ignoring attempts to get herattention. I suspect she may be tired of helping the technically challenged, but this was a case of confirming the items on thetab and being snubbed is a poor way to end a visit. Read more