Reviews for McCullough's Ice Cream Shop in Stoneboro, PA
Good pnut butter shakes, and SanderBrownDog loves their vanilla in a bowl Yummy homemade scoops of butter pecan and black... walnut ice cream for mama, vanilla in a bowl for a special girl Marmie. Can't beat McCulloughs! Read more
Great home town ice cream! So many flavors!
Great food and ice cream.
The best ice cream. Not too sweet. Cold creamy and just right. Yum.
Nice place to get ice cream but for food you better plan on a wait or call ahead. Ordered a chicken salad with fries. 30min or... so later no fries on the salad even though they were asked for 3-4 times when ordering. When I said something the girl was likeno he only asked what was on it but I can put an order in. I already waited to long just for the salad didn't want to wait anylonger. Then it was a weird semi breaded merinaded piece of chicken in a fry basket. Not sure if we will be back. Read more
Ok... it wasn't bad... wasn't great... It is a place a would go back to... I had a steak hoagie and fries... it was all ok...... good ... not bad... Read more
My family loves stopping in for a huge cone! I?ve never tried it, not being able to have dairy, but they all say it?s the best!... Great selection of flavors?might take a long time for little ones to decide ???? Read more
Love their ice cream. Was passing by and stopped and got a small ice cream cone and got my dog a dish of ice cream for a treat.