Reviews for Schumacher's Shanty Pizza and Sandwich Pub in Stockbridge, WI

Totally ripped us off. We ordered the chicken nuggets with fries and got charged for an extra fry, it was supposed to come with... a side. Okay, fine then we have a whole lots extra fries. Except when we got our order we only got a handful of fries. When Iasked the waitress where the extra order of fries were, she asked the bartender. He came over and said she put the extra frieswith the nuggets. There was no way. They didn't seem to care. Read more

Came in twice while staying at calumet park for two weeks. Great and relaxed vibe with good Pizza. We'll come back in next... year when we're back in the area. Time to head south! Read more

Had a wrap and cheese chunks for lunch. All fresh , no deep fryer only hot air fryer. Owner very nice and place is a great old... Wisconsin bar Read more

We didn't eat but food smelled and looked amazing! Fun owners and fun "regulars". A must stop if you are traveling thru the area... or if you are staying nearby! Awesome place! Read more

I started coming in in July of 21 it 30 min drive , but I would drive 2 hour for the cleanest , best food and 2 best owners... that bust there butts everyday to make the experience awesome. The best bartender you will ever meet (Shandra) FYI bestRueben and French dip not to mention the most unbelievable pizza you will ever eat Read more

I asked the locals in town where's there a spot to get some food? This was the only place anyone could really mention. We... checked out the menu and called to place our order. The lady was rude on the phone and the items we asked for off the menu wereapparently not being served anymore. She stated that the menu is not updated with what's available and also the prices arewrong!! So we looked again and called back. My husband got a sandwich that he really enjoyed. We also ordered two chickennuggets. We only saw one in the bag and called back to let them know that they had missed one. They called back after we were onour way back to the restaurant/bar and said that it was two orders in one box? Why would you do that? It was two differentindividuals food and they needed to share? We also ordered a French fry that was four dollars or whatever cause it don't makesense and there was literally just a small handful of soggyness. So I ordered a sandwich, two chicken nuggets, and a fry and itcost me forty dollars? Also when I called they told me 25mins it would be ready for pick up. I showed up 30mins later and waitedan additional 30mins in the restaurant/bar? I also had a difficult time trying to get the attention of the bartender. The insideof the establishment is wonderful but everything else really sucked. Totally ridiculous. My first time there and my last.Definitely not impressed and a little t'd off. I see your other reviews and your apologies but you do nothing to actually makeit right. I am calling for my money back. I was overcharged and never got a receipt. With those kind of prices you would thinkyour sandwich would come with fries or a side! Read more

I used to go there and enjoyed several items on the menu. The last time I went there, a young female bartender was refusing to... serve me. She had served me in the past without issue. I had been seated at the bar for 10 minutes and noticed she hadn'tacknowledged me. So, I moved to a spot closer to where she was thinking she would be able to see me better. When she finallycame around to ask me what I wanted I stated I would like a Dirty Martini. She had a puzzled look on her face. I explained thelady sitting to my right was a bartender at another local establishment and she would be able to explain how to make it if shewas unsure and then I asked for a menu. She stared at me for about 10 seconds and then said "Please"? I asked her if she wasseriously going to refuse a drink and food unless I said please. She just stood there staring at me. I gathered my belongingsand let her know I was leaving and would not be coming back again, as in ever again. I was not rude. I had eaten in thisestablishment many times before. The owners were always kind and I always had good food a great time there, until thishappened. I would be happy to speak with the owners about my experience if they wish to reach out. I have heard other localssay they won't go there because the bartenders were rude and disrespectful to some elderly patrons, but that wasn't myexperience, so I kept on patronizing them, as I do all my local restaurants. One of my friends who was across the street atGobblers Knob (where I did go immediately following my departure) stated if he had been there with me that she never would havedone that. The fact is, regardless of who I am, how I am dressed, who I am with or whatever my age, it never should havehappened. I work in the service industry and I have dealt with rude and disrespectful customers. I was in no way rude ordisrespectful. Read more

Great little bar and grill. Oh, boy! You have to try their pizza. Delish. Good beer selection. Great service and food.