Reviews for Jimmy Max in Staten Island, NY
Ordered pierogi's as my starter and a bar size pizza pie for myself. Both dishes were so SO incredibly great and enough for a... second meal with the leftovers i brought home. This place gives the best portions, meaning generous! You can't go wrong withJimmy Max if trying to have a good experience. Family friendly and on the list of neighborhood staples on Staten Island. Read more
Great pizza. Thin crust. Margherita pizza is very good. Not the cheapest but they make a good pie.
I can only speak to the food and the service. May 30th 2022. I was driving back from JFK and had to pass through my old stomping... grounds Staten Island. I was hungry I almost stopped off of the Belt parkway at a spot but I held on for a little bitlonger. Guys, this pizza tastes amazing. The crust the sauce the cheese the toppings everything was balanced perfectly ( forme*). The crust had the right amount of salt the right amount of sauce was on the dough the right amount of cheese was on thesauce and it wasn't overlaiding with ingredients. The basil was fresh. 5 stars... Jersey pizza does not compare to StatenIsland Pizza much less New York. Anyways! The service at Jimmy Max was wonderful. I asked for square cut and I got square cutwho knows maybe that's the norm but my request was Matt with a smile and accuracy. I like square cut when I'm eating and drivingat the same time. I'll definitely stop there again and probably bring my wife because she deserves the finer things in life aswell. Read more
We had our sisters bridal shower at Jimmy Max today and all I can say is WOW, it was perfect. The new party room is beautiful.... The food was delicious!!! The sangria, mimosa's and drinks were so good. The staff was so friendly, helpful and attentive. Erinand Isabel went out of their way to make our sisters day so special, as did the rest of the staff. I highly recommend havingyour party or gathering there or just go for dinner and drinks, you will not be disappointed . Read more
I've been to this place before with a lifestyles class. For the First time I've learned how to make pizza here and for the... second time i was with another group of people from a different location there. Also it was someone's birthdaytoday.???????????? The Place looked like it hasn't changed since I've been there but I don't mind. It had a good dining area butI still don't know if they deliver. They do have a website but I don't know if it works. I might have to look this place up andsee if they do delivery on their website if they do maybe I might come back to this place with some other group or call or orderonline. The food was delicious and their entrees were good. ???? ???? Read more
Staple of Staten Island. Bar but you can bring your kids.so the Rangers are in the playoffs and we decided to do some take out.... Ready right before puck drop. Food and service never disappoints, if you?re going on a game night go early for a bar seat buttables have Tv?s as well. Try everything you can here. Read more
Just dropped in, they were completely booked, but recommended the bar seating area. I don't normally like bar stools. But we... gave it a try. I won the Urban Fairies of Staten Island Raffle for Jimmy Max one free meal per months for a year. Never beenprior to today. Jessica at the bar and the other lady bartender handled a busy crow with expertise & experience, made everyonefeel welcome. We enjoyed some drinks and had great food! Thank you all! We'll be back! Read more
Just left a Confirmation Party here and the homemade eggplant rollatini, mozzarella sticks, and meatball appetizers as well as... the pizza were all amazing. The Owner and the staff were very friendly and accommodating. I highly recommend you stop here forgreat food and drinks next time you're in the area. Read more