Reviews for Goodfella's in Staten Island, NY
Came in for lunch and I was not disappointed! I was told they are known for their vodka pie and it was delicious, a must have. ... We also started off with the fried calamari , which was good. It was light and tasty. This place has a quiet and cozy vibewhich was good for me wanting to get some work done during lunch. We?ll definitely visit again. Read more
Clam pizza was dry and was not cut/divide properly since it was so dry, it was hard to cut them into a slice. Honey chicken... sandwich was okay and the fries were soggy, the chicken was also dry. Overall not bad but not good either. Read more
Omggg I am still sitting here with my husband, catching a break from the kids lol?I couldn?t wait to leave my review. I still... can?t believe how amazing this Pizza is. The service was excellent! The pizza was so flavorful and the bread is so soft Wowwww!First time here in all the years I?m in Staten island but I?m coming back. My recommendation is to Try the vodka pizza/chickencheddar square (not sure the exact name). The calamari is another amazing appetizer. Thank you!!! Read more
This place was delicious and the service was great! An authentic Italian-American joint. I had the pizza alla vodka and a huge... Long Island ice tea and enjoyed the chuck mangione music playing in the background. Prices were very reasonable for the portionsize too. I?m still dreaming about returning. Go here, you won?t regret it. Read more
My first New York pizza. Excellent flavor beats any pizza where I'm from that's for sure. The hype is real
Food was very delicious, I liked the margarita pie fresh ! Also got the garlic bread which was amazing ! . Spinach artichoke dip... also a good appetizer I would recommend this place for sure Read more
The best service! The team goes above and beyond with their hospitality. The vodka pizza pie is perfect. The food is freshly... made. Great place for groups. We had a team dinner here after the track meet at Ocean Breeze. It was not too crowded. There wasno wait for 12 people on a Saturday late afternoon. Read more
Walked in Great Kills on this beautiful day to check out the new location of Goodfellas. The place is just lovely, with a... pristine bar, loft VIP section and side with many tables facing the brick oven. The modern feel is very welcoming. We sat atthe bar for a little college football and a drink. The place was pretty quiet midday on a Saturday but I?m sure it will pick upas people seek out their awesome menu. Fair pricing, great apps and pizza for sure. Read more