Reviews for Andrew’s Diner in Staten Island, NY
Normal diner and experience. The service was excellent, the food tasty. My pastrami was piled high, the way pastrami was meant... to be! My friend's meal was so totally covered with you couldn't tell what he was having. And that is not a complaint, it's acompliment. Read more
It?s a Staten Island staple and never misses on a meal. The selections are broad and fresh and fabulous every time. Went most... recently for breakfast - high marks for perfectly cooked over easy eggs, perfect huge pancakes and crispy delicious bacon. Read more
Place was busy on a Sunday. Went for a quick bite for a birthday breakfast with the family. Portions were sufficient, our... waitress was sweet. Read more
I ordered a Greek burger and it was a huge pita wrap with a big burger cut in 4 and lettuce and onions throw together with feta... cheese on top Def not a Greek burger or gyro just horrible and it was my first time ordering I might give them another shot atbreakfast I've heard good things about there breakfast dishes. Anyway I hope you have a better experience than I did enjoy andhave a great day Everyone. Read more
Excellent cuisine in a welcoming setting. The waiters and waitresses are very welcoming to families with children, and the... quality of the meal is consistent. In Andrews, I haven't ever experienced a subpar lunch. It is highly recommended that youpartake in one of their delectable brunches. On rare occasions, I do get a bad meal, but they easily fix the problem. Read more
Just a fun diner. The server was present and just really added to the ambiance. My gyro had the earthiness of the lamb cooled by... the sauce and fresh vegetables. Sometime it?s good just to have fun and conversation. Read more
Andrew's Diner is the go to place, by far the best place I've ever been. Food is great and worth every dime and the staff are... friendly and helpful, making a effort to be nice and welcoming, I love this place and wish I could go all the time. Their niceto children and build relationships with the people there, I've known a staff member for years on end and havent seen herrecently, today I went and got to see her again and it was just a very happy reunion. In short, I recommend this place and loveit <3 Read more
First time I was ever disappointed. Waitress must have forgotten to put our order in. Watched her talk to hostess for 7-8... minutes and was concerned our food was sitting and getting cold. To my surprise, when she finally went into kitchen, she didn'tcome out with our food. Other customers who came in after us, who were fortunate enough to get a different waitress, got theirfood before us. After waiting an additional 15 minutes or so, we got our food and our eggs were warm and our bacon was cold. Imay go back because of other past experiences, but will definitely make sure we get a different waitress. Read more