Reviews for Sully's Pub & Grill in Star, ID
We had a lovely time on the patio with two other couples. Our server seemed to be new because she didn't know the menu or the... beer list and couldn't offer suggestions. She seemed to be a bit overwhelmed. Other servers picked up that my meal had still notbeen served after everyone else had their food and got me a cup of soup to go with my overcharred bread. I ended up beingcharged for a bowl, but the cost difference is minimal. We had a mixed bag for dinner. On the good side was the fish and chipsand finger steaks which were seasoned well and cooked properly. The rockfish tacos were good but the fish was a little over, mysoup was lukewarm but tasted okay. The meatloaf was okay but the sauce on it was so inedible that my husband scraped it off andcouldn't eat the mashed potatoes that it sunk into. I think that if you are looking for a relaxing place to drink in the shadeand maybe listen to a band or play cornhole this is a great place to go. You might want to wait for the kitchen or go with thespecials for your meal. Read more
I had the Salmon Salad. It was delicious and filling. Service was great too. I highly recommend.
I've been looking forward to visiting for a few years now and finally was able to make it there. It was kind of a last minute... decision, but good timing. The place was busy and lively. Parking: There is a parking lot with enough room for the restaurant.The spots aren't small so they have plenty of space between cars. Service: the service was great! We were greeted quickly andgiven an option to sit in the back room with heaters. We decided to wait for a table in the main area to get the fullexperience. After a short wait we were seated. We were asked if we would like drinks fairly quickly. The food came out wellspaced. We never felt rushed to leave. Drinks: I had the Guinness on tap. It was smooth and cold in a large glass. My wife gotan old fashioned. Food: The salad was large, cold and crisp. My wife had the meatloaf and it was seasoned well and had a goodflavor. I had the Prime rib and it was tender and the correct redness with good flavor. Read more
Great friendly service! Great food! I was just visiting Idaho for now, but really liked it. This spot was one of the places I... visited more than once. I got a snake bite and tried the Steak tenders that are everything I hoped they'd be, but no photo. Ialso really enjoyed tge Irish Burger too. The bartender/servers are helpful and friendly and gave extra attention to patrons whocame alone which is always nice to see. I also tried a number of items on the menu and was never disappointed. Definitely wortha try if you've never been and/or visiting town, you won't be disappointed. It also seemed very family friendly as i noticedmany familys with young children on my more than one visit. Read more
Not the most excellent menu order. The chicken salad pita should be removed from the menu - so bad... we enjoyed the outdoor... seating but we were overwhelmed with bad food choices and a crowd of 30 who showed up right after we sat down. Read more
Great atmosphere at this pub and grill. The menu is an Irish/German fusion. The food was served fast, though the quality of meat... was not great, especially given the prices on menu. Would definitely come back to watch sports and get appetizer and drinks. Read more
Went here today for some awesome food. We all shared the Coconut Shrimp, Breaded Shrimp, Calamari and an order of Halibut and... Chips. Everything was delish and we could not get enough. Wait staff was pleasant and attentive. Definitely will return for morecoconut shrimp ???? Read more
Stopped in for Happy Hour and had a great time. The prices are reasonable, there are plenty of TVs and Staff is very friendly.... Overall nice experience. Read more