Reviews for Blue Mermaid Seafood & Steak House in St. Catharines, ON

Service, food and environment was fantastic. I am only rating it a 4 because of location

I was waiting for Sinatra to walk in! Had the opportunity to go to the Blue Mermaid with friends. Constantine our server was... very knowledgeable and helpful. Eddie the piano player just added that little extra class to an already classy place. The tableside Caesar salad, oysters Rockefeller along with calamari started the evening. The ladies had lobster while the guys hadpeppercorn steak. Elegant and style. Can?t wait to go back. Read more

This restaurant offers the lost art of fine dining. Food is amazing, best Dirty Martino in town. Cesar salad, oysters, steak,... lobster tail paired with an amazing California wine suggested by the staff. Ended the meal with dessert and a Blue Mermaidcoffee. Quality service and food in an old school atmosphere. We love this restaurant. Read more

I was treated to a lovely dinner at The Blue Mermaid. Dinner here is like a trip back in time, classic and special. If this was... your favourite restaurant 30 years ago, I?ll bet not much has changed since then (except for the menu prices which were prettyhigh). We both had the Chilean sea bass. The portion of fish was generous, it was cooked nicely and the accompanying vegetableswere good. Service was more formal than your everyday restaurant, but still warm, friendly and personable. I?m glad they?restill going strong. Tradition and nostalgia are important in the hospitality game. Read more

Great, local white table cloth steakhouse in St. Catharines. Personally preferred the laid-back lounge, but apparently that's... been closed. Nevertheless, they've brought the piano upstairs to create a cozier atmosphere. We thoroughly enjoyed ourappetizers and mains; however would have preferred the gravy on the side. Otherwise, another delightful evening at Blue Mermaid. Read more

Went here for my girlfriend's birthday. We are new to St. Catharines and everyone raved about how great Blue Mermaid was. After... $400, for an app, 2 entree and 4 drinks total, I would much rather go to other places locally. The food was fine - not great -dated. We were by far the youngest customers there by about 20 years. The service was fine, in fact it was exceptional. But thefood and atmosphere was nowhere near what we paid. Lobster was a little rubbery and over done. Steak was... Fine. Not special.Not worth what you pay. Overall... Fine. Not worth the cash. Way better other spots around. Read more

Food is good. The ceaser salad is the only reason I would go back. Small mignon for $65 for a surf and turf. On the menu stated... $18 for oysters were charged $24 and when we questioned the lovely waitress we could hear the manager yell at her that pricesfluctuate. Understandable but then explain that first. 6 oysters for $24 is quite a bit. Hearing the manager yell at her wasdisturbing. He finally came over and barely apologized for not telling us the cost difference. I didn't care about the $6 it wasthe fact the way the manager spoke to the server was absolutely not warranted. Wont go back anytime soon. Treat your staffbetter and your customers. Guess because we weren't regulars we didn't matter since once all the regulars came in it was allhugs and attention and we were just left in a corner. Read more

There is still such a thing as class and supreme customer service! Skip the Keg and Ruth's! Pleasantly visit the gem of St.... Catharines! You don't hang around for 45 years without top notch customer service! A rare find! The food is nothing less thanexcellent! Delicious, no matter what you order! The King Crab Legs are served as if you were in fact, a King! You don't evenhave to crack them! An absolutely wonderful experience! My go to until I die! Bravo Blue Mermaid! Read more