Reviews for Tigers Pizza & Subs in Spring Lake, NC

First time trying this place. The location was easy to get in and out and away from most traffic in Spring Lake. Shabby-chic... inside but they knew my order when I walked in before giving my name! We ordered two different pizzas, the Tiger pizza(pictured) and a custom one. It was good, fresh tasting and made to order. Definitely good value for the money! Read more

Food is excellent, the staff is great especially Bernie he's the best delivery driver, in store server and now a great friend.... All truth Tiger pizza got it going on in Spring lake Nc. Read more

It?s nice to come back and see you still open and the pizza being the best around. If your from Western NY stop in and get... pizza that tastes like home!!! If you want great pizza from a small business this is your place!! Read more

So far we've only had one experience, ordered a small thin crust cheese pizza and a medium thick crust white cheese pizza with... added sausage. Not super amazing, and definitely not NY style as advertised, but the cheese blend and sauce were very nice. Theprices weren't too bad, but it's definitely more than your average chain restaurant. Will have to try again to see if it's worththe price difference, but for now I'd say it's pretty good. Read more

I could give a no star. I have been ordering from this place for over 7 years. I ordered one today and not once did they... mentioned that they had changed their menu. I have ordered the same thing for 7 years. I called and asked when they changed themenu and he says 3 weeks ago. With that being said when I told him I was allergic to mushrooms and again never said they addedto the salads. He told me next time I?ll just have to order it without it. Mind you 10.69 for the salad, 3.00 for extra cheese1.99 for black olives. He never asked if he could replace it or leave me credit for the next time. Never again. I?m sorry Read more

The place is dingy and very dirty looking. If you can get past that and still decide to order the food is low quality. We got a... half cooked pizza with RAW dough, completely inedible. When we called to ask for a new one to be made or get a refund the ladyover the phone was very rude, insisted that it's supposed to be raw, then hung up when we asked to speak with someone else. Nothappy. Read more

I ordered from tiger pizza in springlake . I ordered $122.00 dollars worth of food and the cheese bread was the only thing that... was good. My grand daughter had a turkey sandwich. They microwave ed it and it had mayonnaise on it it's been two days and sheis still sick . Who does this. They don't care about there food or customer s . Never again will I order from this place and I beg others not to . Read more

Had a 10" pepperoni & jalapeno. Food was Good quality. Hot & fresh however it wasn't what I expected. It's NOT NY style hand... tossed. The crust is a bit thick (not foldable)for my liking, but Still very enjoyable if you're into a thicker hand tossedcrust. Read more