Reviews for Benny's Pizza & Restaurant in Spring Lake, NJ
Very slow delivery doordash dont go order never ready and take like 20 minutes to be ready rude merchant
Wow! So delicious. We ordered big for movie night. Went all out with chicken Frances, lasagna, meatballs, salads and lava cakes,... tirimisu. It was hands down the best food we have had out in a while. It was so good I told my 13 yr old to shut up for 5 minand let me enjoy it in peace. Lol. Def will order again. Read more
We have been ordering from here for years now. Every. Single. Time...we are greeted with a smile and a thank you for being a... customer. The food is delicious, made with all fresh ingredients at a very good price. You feel at home instantly where theowner makes you feel like family. I tell everyone how great Benny?s Pizza is. Don?t miss out. Read more
A disaster from start to finish. I called and ordered baked ziti with a side order of meatballs. I also wanted to order... broccoli. The person who answered the telephone said I could not order broccoli as a side order. I said I HAD TO HAVE AVEGETABLE with my dinner as a matter of health. He said I'd be getting some mixed vegetables with the dinner. Fine. The dinnercame, and there were no vegetables at all and no salad dressing for my salad. I had ordered Italian dressing on the side. Icalled up and the young man told me NO vegetables were included and he had made a mistake. Then he informed me all of a suddenthat he COULD send over a broccoli side order and it would be an additional seven dollars and it would be a half an hour later.Fine. An hour later NO sign of the broccoli. Every time I called the place I was put on hold for a long period of time. PS thebread that came with the dinner was stale. They really need to get their act together. VERY DISORGANIZED. Read more
Best sicilian pizza your taste buds will ever experience. The atmosphere and service is top notch with a smile. The second you... walk in you feel like your Nona's on a Sunday afternoon. Read more
Benny's is one of my favorite places to go. The food is delicious- the nonna pie and the white pizza with broccoli are my... favorites. We order pizza and catering from benny's often. The food is consistently good and the owner (Izzy) is very nice andgoes out of his way to make sure you are happy. When my father was sick (my dad was also a regular customer), Izzy gave us freesoup to take home to him. I highly recommend Benny's Read more
Throughout this pandemic I have made an effort to consistently support local restaurants. Sadly, we have never had any luck... with Bennys. While the pizza is good, the service is absolutely horrible! We have never ever gotten a delivery even close to thetime promised. Going in person is no better!! I waited in person almost an hour on several occasions. Not worth the aggravationin my opinion. Read more
Have had Bennys a few times via door dash. Great food! I especially am a fan of the chicken Francaise with veggies mashed... potatoes side salad and bread! Delicious and I think portioned enough for 2 if you also get the avocado salad! Yum! Read more