Reviews for Montgomery's Steakhouse in Spiceland, IN
We got the Montgomery cut steak and it was delicious! My sides were a wedge salad and a baked potato. The salad was big enough... for a meal on its own or to split. The potato was huge but I like mine a little more done. Service was great. I woulddefinitely go again if I was in the area. They had both indoor and outdoor seating and there were several kids in therestaurant. We didn't get dessert, too full from dinner. Read more
Decided to take my Dad out for Father's day and we had heard it was very good. Arrived at 4:45 and we were told that it would be... a 20 minute wait. Good not bad for Father's day. Waited 45 minutes to an hour and we only had 1 couple ahead of us. Seatingarea is very small. Ordered the New York Strip, baked potato and a Ceasars salad. The steak was good but not great. The saladwas very good and the bread was alright. Baked potato was a good size but was over cooked. The young man who waited on us wasvery good and came to us regularly to ask if we needed anything. I would not go back again any time soon. For the price I couldhave gone somewhere else and gotten better food for the money. So disappointed. Read more
Edited to add more pictures and to say this is my favorite place grab lunch when I come thru Been here 3 times service was good... food was flavorful Read more
Man if you are anywhere near knights town or Wilkinson, or even just passing through these areas, please stop by. This place has... amazing food, draft, and service. I had the New York strip medium well, and it was fantastic. My guest said their chicken wasamazing. I couldn't stop eating the crispy steakhouse fries, even when I was full, I had to have more. This place is great ifyou have the time to wait for perfection Read more
Food was amazing service was awesome server was amazing as well. First review is when I first went there this review steak was... amazing hands down whoever changed the recipe or if they bought Store bag mac and cheese no first time I ever ate there my lifeit was made homemade like you make it home that's the way to go mac and cheese was not good Read more
Stop by here on my way Indy. Decor and atmosphere was fairly nice. Service was slow for 130pm lunch. My wife and I ordered the... wings and fried appetizer combo. Just slightly better than bar food. We were provided the most underwhelming free bread as well?overall C+ Read more
I come In From the road looking for good food. It's a nice establishment true steakhouse style. I sit down order. It doesn't... print to the back and I notice that the bartender (my waitress) is new and isn't to keen on checking to make sure things areright 2 orders went out ahead of mine that I was before. I say something. I get food instantly. However steak was undercooked Iordered med rare it was rare. I was hungry I'm not going to throw a fix. It was ok but underseasoned the Brea was bland the Macand cheese was cheap no zing and the potatoes I can put my finger one were not that great. That being said where this is at itsthe best you will find and mistakes happen. Read more
Prime Rib was absolutely delightful, great Service, Excellent Drinks, staff was very nice, very neat establishment, would... definitely drive over an hour again to dine here! Loved it! ?????????? Read more