Reviews for Michelangelo Speonk in Speonk, NY
Lunch was so good we came back for dinner. Don't miss out on this gem of a place.
Best pizza on Long Island, period. Italian dishes are also incredible
Friendly staff. I really like their food especially pizza, chicken parmesan, rice balls, meat balls, tiramisu, everything. I am... really in love with their chicken parmesan. I had it multiple times, never once dry. It was so tender and juicy. Read more
By far the worst take away pizza I?ve had. Sloppy. Feels like extremely cheap ingredients. Ironically I ordered sushi but far... from here and it was the worst sushi I?ve had. I rushed out to get pizza. Lesson, avoid any restaurant in east port / westHampton. Judge a book by its cover. Read more
Just before the pandemic, we went to Michelangelo?s in SPEONK at least 4x a month. Now we do take out. The food is... exemplary! Everything is FRESH and delicious. The owners and staff are just wonderful and accommodating! Their pizzas are thebest of the best. I just ordered a take out last night and once again it was hot, delicious, and I couldn?t have cooked better!(And I?m of Italian decent ???????????) Read more
These guys do not know what they are doing. They make poor wings and they've burnt BOTH pies at the bottom and top. How do you... burn 2 pizza pies and give it to a customer? I understand we are in a pandemic, but that's no excuse to provide a customer apoor product time and time again. Read more
Very nice staff, good pizza and specialty slices are really good. Heros are very good too, we get them often at work. My only... complaint is the balsamic dressing; no matter what I ask, I always seem to get a cup of cooking oil with a drop of balsamicvinegar at the bottom. My favorite is the grilled chicken hero with the salad on it, but sometimes I have no dressing because Igot a cup of oil instead. A little update: I actually went and asked what I should specifically ask for to get the dressing Iwant. Settled on just asking for straight balsamic vinegar, no oil. Today I got balsamic glaze, again. I wonder what thelanguage barrier is. Sandwich is still good, anyway. Everything is always fresh and properly cooked, and that's the mostimportant thing. Still annoyed about my balsamic vinegar though... Read more
Hold on short notice, ask them to accommodate a group of 15 including six kids they said yes showed up they were ready food was... great they over accommodated us and my rowdy group of boys thank you Read more