Reviews for The Cotter Pin in Sparta, WI
Very Nice atmosphere & staff!! Wasn't fond of the soup. But the sandwiches Rocked! People there are All Good Folks..
The cotter pin never misses! A changing drink menu offers continuous new experiences. The atmosphere is great! I highly... recommend the cotter pin. Read more
Driving from Dubuque, Iowa to Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin and needed a pit stop. We ordered a couple of appetizers, which were... very good. Had a couple of beers. People and staff were friendly and service was good. If we're in the area again, definitelygoing to make another stop. Read more
Evie, the waitress was polite, friendly and attentive. Menu questions were answered quickly and accurately. Food was very good... especially the mac and cheese. Sangria was refreshing. Read more
Had a fantastic meal at the Cotter Pin last night! We were looking for a new place to try and this fit the bill. Even as we... walked in from the parking lot there was a very nice gentleman that held the door open for us (the owner maybe?). Charter hadgone out so they didn't have TVs or card machine but the ATM still worked. The prime rib for us and pizza for the kids wasexcellent! The atmosphere was great and everyone working there was SO friendly and nice! We're definitely going back! Read more
Excellent service. Not only did my server check in frequently, the cook also checked in with me to make sure my food was okay. I... had the Reuben which was really good. The bread was nice and crisp, not the least bit soggy. I also had a bloody mary and had achoice of flavored vodkas. Dill, garlic, bacon or plain and I chose the dill. Read more
My wife and stopped on a Saturday afternoon around 1ish, very cool place inside but overall was kind of a downer experience. ... The waitress wasn't the friendliest to begin with, I ordered the Reuben and was brought a French dip, I told her I had theReuben and she came back quickly with my sandwich, it hardly had any sauerkraut on it and had no 1000 island dressing on it, ornone in a container, I went to the bar to ask for some and they didn't really seem to sorry about it, the waitress didn'tapologize at all. First impressions are everything and I'm not sure if we would go back. Read more
Bloody Mary's were EXCELLENT and so was the food. My wife got the Reuben Mac 'n Cheese. Sounded like a weird combo, but it was... absolutely amazing. I had a quesadilla and it was seriously the best I ever had. Really good flavor. We'll be back! Read more