Reviews for COSMO'S PIZZERIA in Southern Shores, NC
Amazing Pizza!! Amazing Cheesy Garlic bread and sauce!! Amazing service!!! Very helpful and knowledgeable about menu and quite... simply among the best tasting pizza places I have ever been to, and I have been to a lot. Great prices as well!! Must have,highly recommend!!! Read more
Ordered the Tuesday special which is MORE than affordable, even adding toppings. Pizza was delicious, literally ate it for... dinner, snack, breakfast, and lunch. Employees were pleasant when picking up, and they have to go plates and condiments at thefront counter. Read more
We went there on a recommendation of some other folks to try the pizza and pasta. The only reason I gave them two stars was the... meatballs for the pasta were very good. That's where it ends. I should have known from the start when phoning in an order on aMonday evening they told me it would be an hour and 10 minutes before my order was ready to be picked up. When I got there theyweren't that busy. They were just timing every time they made a pizza. The pizza had an okay crust but the sauce was quite Blandand the cheese mix was not that great. I had ordered a cheese pizza and couldn't understand where they five tablespoons ofGrease came from. The pasta was okay but the marinara tasted more like tomato sauce with a couple of pieces of onion and maybethere was some garlic. Even dousing it with parmesan cheese didn't help this pasta. A small cheese pizza and a spaghetti andmeatball cost me about $30 out the door. This had to be the most frustrating meal that I ever had to wait an hour and a half toget. Needless to say I will not be back. Read more
Potato Pizza!! It's the real deal! Top 5 pizza in my lifetime. Rest of family had large cheese, crust made it! Thin, crispy,... and a great bite. Read more
I'd rate this higher than 5 if I could. PHENOMENAL gluten free pizza. Like ... do not even Consider trying anything else if this... place is open. Hands down best gluten free I've ever encountered. I'll be back if I'm ever in the area! Read more
The family enjoyed a quick stop for pizza on our way to the beach. As a New Yorker I'm picky when it comes to pizza and I will... eat here again Read more
The pizza was great but we first hand experienced the wrath of the lady that I'm sure is the same one mentioned in many other... reviews. My credit card got misplaced and she told me that she must have given it to another customer. I told her that Iwould pay with another card but that it was an issue because I would now have to cancel our card. She got angry and walkedaway. I eventually found the card under the pizza box, but when I went up to give it to her she became even more angry. Shefinally ran the card and of course at that point I left no tip. She told us to never come back. Very disappointing, I can'trecall ever being treated like this before. We've been banned from a place we wouldn't want to go back to anyway:) Read more
Mom and Pop Pizza joint. Don't let the shopping center fool ya. They are in full operation and have taken great care of us.... Pizza is smoking hot coming out, crust has a crunch, sauce and cheese are perfect! Read more