Reviews for Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant in Southampton, NY

Good prices, service was a little slow but the food was great.

Excellent Pizza! I had the mushroom pizza and you need to try the Garlic Knots. It was very busy when we got there, but found... seating at the bar. The bar keeper was very friendly! Read more

By far THE absolute best pizza in the Hamptons. Ingredients are always fresh and service is friendly and prompt.

My girlfriend and I had dinner here. We initially sat in the cute little patio dotted with flowers and moved inside after some... drinks. The garlic knots are absolutely amazing and should not be passed up. One of the main reasons we tried this place istheir gluten free pasta option. We have eaten a lot of gluten free pasta, and I have to say this was one of the best. Absolutelyamazing food. The service staff was as attentive as possible, as it was a full house on a Saturday. All in all, I woulddefinitely love to come back for another meal. Read more

This is our favorite restaurant in the Hamptons! The pizza is always delicious, the drinks are amazing, and the servers always... take such great care of our family. Read more

It felt a bit discombobulated when I arrived, maybe they were changing shifts but I felt like I led the way in sitting down and... having to place my order. The meatballs were delicious but the pizza was just okay? next time I?ll try a meal. Read more

The garlic rolls have me forever changed. They were AMAZING! I ordered the white pizza and it was delicious. My son(super picky... eater) ate half a pizza, and my mother in laws Chicken Milanese was incredible! Exceptional service! Love this spot! Read more

Cute little place. Our waitress mumbled so it was especially hard to hear her with her mask on. The garlic knots were strange.... More like mini loaves of bread than actual knots and they were a little tough but the flavor was good. The beer on tap was freshand the serving was huge. We split a pizza and it's not that big, but it was pretty good. Read more