Reviews for Paul's Italian American Restaurant in Southampton, NY
Great experience here! We were served by Kylie, and she was awesome. She took her time to help us find options on the menu that... would cater to our vegetarian preferences for the night, made jokes, and just overall made it an enjoyable dining experience.The quality of food was great, thankfully it wasn?t overly salty like a lot of Italian places. The garlic bread was amazing!!Most entrees were between $20-$30 and comes with garlic bread and salad. If I?m ever in this area again I?d definitely comeback. Read more
We both had chicken Parmigan. The chicken was bad. It tasted a smelled awful. We told the waitress who sent the owner to our... table. He actually became angry at us and told us not to come back. We were shocked and immediately left. You decide. I evenoffered for him to try the chicken and he refused. Quite funny actually. Read more
This goes way back, I was visiting my grandmother in 1976, I lived with her for few months, one evening we were at the cinema... few doors away if I remember right, the movie was Logan run ???????? any way afterward we went to Paul?s pizza and I had themost unforgettable introduction to there beautiful pizza, I have never forgot that evening nor that pizza ???? I?ve told thisstory to many friends back home in Edinburgh Scotland, they don?t understand the difference in taste and quality. Brilliant???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? Read more
Beware of over charging - prices on online menu and printed menus are not accurate. Menu priced linguine with clams and shrimp... entree for $20.95. I was charged 31.95 instead.. Owner claimed that seafood prices have gone up and he did not have time toupdate the menu. The entree was very basic- linguini with clam sauce and 2 shrimp. Not a single clam. Read more
I am very picky with the meat that I chose. It?s always either really burnt or too dry. Well this place hit the spot. The sauce... was delicious and the meat was perfect. The portion sizes and the prices are actually good considering it?s in the Hamptons. Theonly downside was that we waited a longer time than usual for the waiter. The place is clean and COVID safe. Read more
Great place to dine in or to take out. The stuff is super friendly, the service was super fast, and the food was great. The... dishes were so big we could hardly finish all and we definitely have to come back to try the deserts. They also have greatselection for breakfast or variety of Pizzas to grab on the go. Read more
Paul's Italian Restaurant was beautiful.... Food was Delicious and the Prices are Amazing. This Restaurant has a large menu... there is definitely something for Everyone here. The Staff here is very friendly especially our waitress (sorry I didn't get hername.) I also had the pleasure of meeting The Owner Paul! Who was extremely pleasant and very kind. I highly recommend thisplace for a lunch or dinner out with the family.. I will most certainly be coming back... Read more
If you are in Southampton, or just the Hamptons in general and want REAL, AUTHENTIC, Italian American Cuisine, Paul's Italian... American Restaurant is the place to be. With the most outrageous Manicotti around, fantastic attentive service and an extremelycozy atmosphere, it is a perfect spot right off of main street for dining. Out of every other Italian restaurant in the villageof Southampton, this truely lives up to having the quality and restaurant experience you look for when eating out. 10/10 Read more