Reviews for Clamman Seafood Market Caterer in Southampton, NY
Run far away from this place!! My hubby and I just ordered two fisherman platters and the only thing tasty was the 3 scallops in... the platter. Everything else was overcooked and bland including the fries. My piece of fried fish was literally like friedjerky. We ate some of it since we spent the money but will NEVER return. It's unfortunate because the people were nice but Iwouldn't trust their cooking. It may be ok for fresh seafood you bring home and cook yourself though my experience has left abad taste in my mouth. LITERALLY! Read more
The fish is great, even the farmed salmon. It is pricey as of June 2022. Not sure if it's a general market issue or this place.... The staff was very nice Read more
Do not order the shrimp po boy. First, they don?t ask if you want on a roll or wrap. Second, they put 2 pieces of shrimp in... this. It taste like a salad. Pure lettuce that?s it. First time I came here and probably last. Very disappointed. Read more
I went there for clam chowder and very disappointing. Chowder had little to no flavor clams were not appropriate chopped up... barely cut as a matter of fact. Very little seasoning even with salt and pepper added still had almost no taste. Vegetables verylittle in the actual container soup had to be microwaved was not already heated. Wound up with horrific heartburn from atasteless soup. All for 20 bucks plus tax. Avoid the soup! Read more
Fresh seafood is not hard to find on an island. Would be nice if they had an edge. They're cooked food is okay. Nothing special... here. i would definitely recommend it. Not to be avoided by any means. Read more
Lots of eager regulars lining up out the door. They only allow four people inside at a time during the pandemic. Few outdoor... tables available. Everything was hot and fresh and made to order! Definitely recommend if you?re in South Hampton cravingseafood. Read more
Called in an ordered takeout, was told 20 minutes and it took an hour and 10. I arrived after 20 minutes and the staff was... incredibly rude. I ordered 3 fried fishermen's platters and everything was over fried. Also it stated that it came with flounderbut for some reason, we received cod. I also asked for a small amount of lobster salad (after waiting 30 minutes in the store)to try and the employees continued to talk about how weird it was to order so little as if I weren't 3 feet away from them. I'mglad I didn't ask for a half of a pound because it was terrible anyway. If you like this place, you'd find any other seafoodmarket out east incredible. Cheaper and better quality. Read more
Have been coming for years. Seafood is impeccable. Service is excellent and friendly and helpful.