Reviews for Blu Mar Hamptons in Southampton, NY
Let’s go on a journey most appalling. Had reservations at 8pm, did not get seated until 9:30. Nary an apology was given. Wait... staff took drink orders but they didn’t show up for another 20 mins. Then came the food ordering, which also never appeared atthe table. Now by this point it is 10:30. 2 and a half hours past our reservation, no food, only a couple drinks. After finallygiving up, we decided to just leave and asked for the bill which had $500 on it for food we never even received and drinks wenever received. We thankfully got the bill finagled down to $300. Worst experience of my entire left. We’re from Skaneateles,NY and I’ve never had this experience at The Krebs or Elephant and the Dove. The only bright guiding bright light in thisexperience was Nico the bartender, what a gem! Never going back here tho. Read more
It was hard to give this place even a star. It was extremely political. The reservation was under my name and I do not identify... as white. We did not receive our food but payed 500+ dollars. When we asked politely to just speak with a manager our serversaid “no I am the manager”.... but yet showed no proof and continued to charge us incorrectly. Read more
Amazing experience at Blu Mar, Myself and friends had dinner here Friday night. Highly recommend the watermelon Margarita. All... the staff were very attentive and had a warming welcome for our birthday celebration! Food is incredible! We'l be back soon :) Read more
My friend and I thought the octopus was fabulous!! Also the Squid ink zuppa de pesce was out of this world. Blueberry Mojito... excellent. Atmosphere service great. But oddly enough I need to agree with. Other reviewers the pizza was awful!! Spongy tastesfrozen -the chef owner needs reality testing Perhaps the pizza maker is not the same chef as the one that made The seafood pasta& octopus. It is very hard two make tender well seasoned Grilled octopus & a really delicious sauce & seafood combo. My husbandis from sicily & we cheat buy focaccia fresh. -ship from balthazar & then put cheese & sauce you cant go wrong. Better small &fresh than large & spongy ???? ps please dont yell at me we did not send the pizza backjust want to help Read more
The staff was just absolutely amazing. They treated us as if we were royalty. The food was an extravaganza. The combinations of... tastes and textures and presentation. A simple dish like Brussels sprouts became a complex medley of sweet punctuated by theaddition of grapes. This simple dish was a journey. This is a must go to spot here!! Read more
Absolutely one of the worst meals I’ve ever had. I added a picture of the clearly frozen pizza that was $20 on the menu.... Honestly can not believe that people come here and spend any sort of money. The wait staff was very nice and was not surprisedby how much we disliked our meal. Zach Erdem should be ashamed to have his name on the menu Read more
The staff are amazing and the food is perfect. We had a good size party and they kept the food and drinks well supplied. We... thank them for all that they've done! Read more
Unsettling and unprofessional experience...planned a birthday dinner outside for 8 and decided to try Blu Mar after viewing... their social media and seeing they had a happy hour and live band on Friday from 4-7. When we arrived at 5:30, a hostess notedthat we had to rush because they changed their mind and the happy hour was ending at 6. With many waiters and the manager eyeingus for 5 minutes, another individual came over and said the restaurant decided not to offer the happy hour and there would be nolive band. This interaction felt like a complete SCAM! They see a table of young girls and decide to completely dishonor whatthey advertised on their social media and on the phone when I called? The staff was sketchy and we should have left the momentwe arrived. Our waiter was kind, but the food was some of the worst I have had at a restaurant. The pasta tasted like watery oilwith no salt or flavor...GO SOMEWHERE ELSE. Read more