Reviews for Costello's Pizzeria & Wings in Smithville, NJ
So I've been going to Costello's for years. But the past few times I've ordered it was terrible. I never waste food but I threw... away half the pizza and I love pizza so for me to not finish what I order is very rare. I ordered tails on another order and acouple of the tenders were hard so I threw away at least 2 of the tenders. Read more
Good food, huge servings, moderate prices, friendly, efficient service, a relaxing atmosphere in a clean, welcoming, space. No... need to dress up either. What more could you ask? Read more
Costello's Pizza Smithville. I went in here to get 2 slices. Right away guy asks how I was paying since I was pulling out my... debit. He says 10 dollar minimum so can maybe get another slice (3) or a soda. I got the extra slice total was 9.60. Wasn'treally happy about that since I get slices all over and never get told 10 min. It is not really a convenient location, at theback of the little stores so you have to park a bit away. Normally, if I get told 10 minimum anywhere I walk, but I was alreadythere. I try to support the small business and when Corona started a lot of places were not sure if they were going to stay inbusiness or whatnot and really wanted people to come in. I guess everybody jumping on the pandemic bandwagon now sincebusinesses found they really did better-not worse, could charge the American people MORE and get away with it. Patriots! Pizzawas a little undercooked. He threw it in the oven 2 minutes so was just tad warm, not hot. 3 stars. Read more
It was TERRIBLE. We ordered a Margherita Pizza, first they put Whole Canned Tomatoes from a can on it, No Pizza Sauce. Way to... much sauce, Soggy Soggy Soggy. Was Terrible. Counter girls need to learn what Customer Service is, unfriendly. Read more
Best pizza ???? in Galloway. I literally just placed my order about 15 minutes ago, it?s already at my house ???? hot , fresh... and good ????! One time they forgot my bag of chips with my sub, I let them know and they brought me a bag of chips with noproblem. Read more
Hands down the absolute best wings I have had anywhere! Everytime I'm up there I make it a point to stop by for wings and... pizza.There are 2 entrances. One is for dining and the other is for pick up. However, you can dine in the latter as well. It'slocated in the Smithville Village which is adorable and full of little shops, bakeries, and candy shops. Read more
The pizza is great here: plain, pepperoni, white etc, whatever you get, slice or whole pie is very good. But the steak subs are... where it's at. Probably the best place in Galloway if not the county. However, the fries aren't so hot. I think they wrap themup right out of the fryer for pickups. They're never crisp like fries should be. You guys step up your fry game and it's 5 starsfor sure. Read more
The pizza was great. The customer service was excellent. Small though. Full menu and the do bring the food to the table if you... are dining in. Sports on the two TV's on the inside. Better for take out by the slice. Good sandwiches. Read more