Reviews for Mayflower Seafood Restaurant in Smithfield, NC
This place is AWESOME. It beats the Goldsboro location hands down. The staff, cleanliness, and food ( taste and proportions),... well exceed any other seafood place within 50 miles. Its the only location I will eat seafood around this area... Great jobguys... Keep up the excellent work. Read more
How do you screw up sweet tea? If their tea is made with a powdered mix, I'd say it has been contaminated with mouse urine. If... it was actually brewed, then something has happened to their tea bags. Neither of us could manage more than a couple swallows,and requested ice water be brought to us. My broiled shrimp were mostly raw. The clam strips were, however edible. We will notbe returning. Read more
This place is very calming and pescatarian friendly! The vibe is very relaxing and they serve dishes like pasta, salads, soup,... sandwiches, and of course yummy seafood platters. I got the catfish platter with shrimp, fries, and hush puppies! Verydelicious! ????! Read more
What a wonderful discovery! Instead of heading to Raleigh, I was so glad to find a delicious, fresh, PLENTIFUL option here in... Clayton. The place was vlean, brightly light, airy and smelled absolutely delicious!I ordered the lunch combo of popcorn shrimpand tilapia with a side of fries, hushpuppies and slaw...all piled high ????. I recommend! Read more
Very good meal! The fried oysters and grouper were great; tasted like they just came off the fisherman's boat. The... scallops...not so much, but they were ok. The service we received was very good, too; our waitress kept the ice tea coming. Note to newbies like me: when they have taken your order and are collecting the menus, when they casually ask if they can "startyou off with some mozzarella sticks or fried pickles?"...know that those items are not going to be free ;) Read more
Service was exemplary. It has a cool nautical atmosphere and was clean and COVID safe. So I hate to leave a bad review. But, The... catfish was kinda like chewing paper with the breading falling off. The flounder was just okay. Fry?s and hush puppies weresoggy.everything was kinda bland. I don?t like spicy food at all so if I say bland it is lol. Salad was excellent. Portions werelarge. Plenty to bring home to the pups. Very nice place. We think it might be geared toward the senior crowd. With the over 55specials and closing so early. Unlike other places we?ve been, we?ll probably try it again. Sometimes the time of day or thecook on duty makes a big difference. $34 for our meals plus a $5 tip. It?s a really nice place and great people. It deserves asecond chance. Read more
Actually the service was not that good there were 3 different sets of people that came in in 10-15 minute intervals after we... did they got there food before we did,started to walk out ,but decided to stay,finally got food grouper was good, potato wasn'thot , oysters were oyster nuggets nothing but burnt flour covering ?? Won't get them again ,tea was a glass of surgar couldn'ttaste the tea,,,used to come here all the time will have second thoughts now..yes that is what the oyster mcnuggets lookedlike.. Read more
We ordered pick up for an office lunch. It was all really good. I got the clams and scallops with fried okra and I loved it, the... scallops were really good! Read more