Reviews for Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille Sister Bay in Sister Bay, WI

The staff was extremely friendly and helpful, the food was fresh and delicious, and while good music was playing it was low... enough we could have a great conversation without having to yell at each other. Also a fantastic assortment of beer totry! UPDATE: We had to go back and try the pizza. The atmosphere yet again was comfortable, clean, GREAT service, good beer wasdrunk, the cherry cheese cake was so goooood, and the Green and Gold Pizza IS NOW MY FAV PIZZA. I've never had such good pizzasauce. Hands down will be coming back every time we visit Door County. 11 out of 10 stars. Read more

We visited for the first time on 10/24/22. Food was amazing! Staff was great. We ordered the Parmesan knots for an appetizer and... they were so light and airy! Their marinara is excellent! For the pizza we ordered the Green & Gold pizza, it had broccoli,spinach, chicken, bacon, with cheese curds on top! So good!! Read more

Wild tomatoes is a must visit place since 2015 for me and my friends, whenever we make a stop in door county we eat here. The... food here is just great as the other branch, awesome flavors, specially the veg pizza is very flavorful. This branch is very bigand with faster service. Will visits again and again! Note: parking is behind the restaurant, it?s mostly crowded but you canfind the spot in 5-10 mins. Read more

Having never been to the thumb of Wisconsin, this restaurant is a solid place to stop. The cheese curds were on point and the... wood fired Margherita pizza. The taste and texture of the crust reminded me of some of the New York style pizza I've had inNYC. Pretty good standards considering pizza coming out of the Midwest. Not to mention this place has pretty good locationsituated on the main strip of Sister Bay Read more

Was super excited to go get pizza after not having it for a few months, and my friend and I were highly disappointed today?got a... large old school pizza, perfectly cooked and tasted delicious. Then opened our box for our build your own pizza, chicken, bacon,pesto, and caramelized onions. We were super excited to dig into this $35 pie only to find that it was burnt. How can you burnone pizza and not the other but yet it was for the same order? And not only that but when we called they said it would be 15minutes, which normally it?s an hour wait. So it was slow and you still gave us a burnt pie? Not sure how soon I will be goingback? Read more

After hearing a lot about this place,wanted to try it out. Had to convince our group to have dinner here because we had sonny... pizza the other night. No one wanted to have pizza for dinner two nights in a row . But man!! This pizza was awesome . We lovedthe vegan/vegetarian pizza it was fresh and flavourful full . We also had the pomegranate lemonade which was good. The cheesecurds were a let down . Because it was too oily and tasted bland Read more

Their wood-fired pizzas are delicious! All the staff are super nice, and seem to be enjoying themselves and having a great time.... Inside atmosphere is nice, a bit on the loud side (due to it being pretty packed), and there is outdoor seating available too. Read more

My first time trying cheese curds and they were mind blowing!!There are various options to customize your pizzas with different... toppings .You would want to check out this place if you are ever in Door county. Read more