Reviews for Buffalo Bill's Tavern & Grill in Show Low, AZ

The staff was very friendly. The cod taco's were really good. The fries were good but on the lukewarm side. We had the pizza as... well which came out with the wrong toppings. We told the waitress about the mistake but said we would just eat it anyway. Thewaitress told her boss and they discounted or pizza. We didn't ask for it to be discounted, I just wanted her to tell thekitchen staff to be more aware. I wasn't complaining by any means, so that was nice they did that for us. So I'm giving a 4 forthe fries and the mistake on the pizza. Other than that, we will go back and have more tacos. Oh and I really wanted to try thepot pie but they didn't have any. Next time I hope they have the pot pie. Read more

Love this place! Nice clean environment with exceptional service. Food is outstanding.

Great food and pet friendly! We sat on the patio for a great view. Service was attentive and genuine. We had a mule and... huckleberry cocktail along with a shared burger with onion rings and potato wedge appetizer. We were told the pickles werehomemade which tasted great along with all the burger toppings, very fresh and overall great meal. Read more

The atmosphere is top notch. Our server was excellent, it did seem like there was a hold up on our cocktails, maybe there were a... bunch of golfers drinking. I ordered the pot roast, I was a little surprised it cam in a bowl. It tasted good but it was almostmore like a soup. Read more

First time customer of Buffalo Bill?s Tavern and Grill and I absolutely loved it! They offer a variety of food (including pizza... with gluten-free crust). We came in with a large group and were taken care of extremely well! The servers were happy, friendlyand helpful. The location is absolutely stunning! I love that they decorated for the Fourth of July. Where we were sat therewere wax figures of historical old westerners like Billy the Kid and Doc Holiday. The restrooms were well maintained and cleanbut do not offer changing tables for little ones. The food and adult beverages were delicious! I had the potato skins with ranchand I would absolutely order them again. This restaurant is a little pricey but well worth your money. I would highly recommendtrying Buffalo Bill?s if you?re around the area! Read more

Added the bison patty and an egg to my melt. Clever move I must say. ???? Good food with good service. Pet-friendly patio for... the fur babies. Read more

Good was good! I loved my chicken salad (not enough dressing to go unfortunately) my husband said his pot pie needed some salt.... Overall it was good. We got it to go so maybe that?s why?? Read more

An excellent home cooked style meal! Reasonably priced I had the Ribeye. Outstanding local beef, cooked beautifully. The mashed... potatoes were tasty, green beans fresh and well seasoned along with a very good side salad. All of the food was well prepared,fresh and of an excellent quality. My friend had the cowboy french dip sandwich on fresh marble rye which she just raved about.The Cesar salad she enjoyed as well. This was a warm, western themed environment and our waitress Taylor was an absolutedelight! Great family choice too. The Smore dessert pictured was AMAZING!!! Read more