Reviews for Carlo's Pizza Shirley in Shirley, NY
I work across the street at the gas station in a booth. Keep in mind I'm a very generous tipper and when I called them & asked... can you guys deliver , the girl on the phone said " we don't deliver" and hung up. Absolute disgrace . Read more
Carlos is a great place to get food, great atmosphere and great customer service. The teens and young adults behind the counter... are all very respectful and well spoken. BBQ Chicken slice and their dinners are great as well. 10/10 Pizzeria Read more
This place is great, family owned, always busy so you know there pizza is good! It?s always fresh and made to order which I... love. So many options for specialty pizza. And def reasonably priced compared to other pizzerias now a days. 10/10 would goagain and again Read more
Hands down 1 of the best pizzerias in Suffolk County. A absolute MUST stop if going east or west on the LIE. Its right off the... exit for William Floyd pkwy. Order ANYTHING its all good NOTHING bad. Read more
This used to be one of my favorite pizza places. It is now run by a bunch of teenagers who care more about their phones then... they do the customers. The pie I received today was undercooked and barely had any cheese. I also ordered a platter ofspaghetti with tomato sauce and got spaghetti and meatballs. The meatballs took up half the platter and I am not a fan ofmeatballs so it is a waste. A few days ago I ordered spaghetti with tomato sauce and they didn't put the tomato sauce in! Theylaughed and said I never asked for sauce. Do people actually order plain spaghetti?!?! This is my last time ordering from here.It is a shame. I used to love this place and looked forward to ordering from them almost weekly. Read more
$3 is the standard for a slice now, i get it. But my kids were still hungry because the slice was so much smaller than a typical... pizza place. Not enough vegetarian specialty slices. Pizza tastes good though. Read more
Familial restaurant with quality food at good value. High traffic of orders for pick-up. Drinks by fountain sodas and bottled... beers/sodas. Staff efficient. Ample parking in lot outside. Read more
Being one if the only pizza places in the area, it was pretty crowded but good was hot & staff efficient