Reviews for Welcome Market Hall in Sheridan, WY

We were there on a Wednesday and was served in the smaller coffee room. It was very quiet and quaint. However on Saturday it was... not. They had a three piece band that was too loud at 6:00 pm. You couldn?t hear each other. We did move outside. That helped.However the food came out cold. Very disappointed. Read more

While staying nearby at the lovely Sheridan Inn, we twice dined here. Avocado toast and scrambled eggs for breakfast. Delicious... coffee. Fig, prosciutto, blue cheese pizza and a garlicky Caesar salad for dinner. Both meals were perfectly excellent. Theatmosphere in this renovated train station is very upscale and modern. The sprawling layout does challenge the staff as theybustle over so much square footage. Still, be patient. This is a very worthwhile restaurant with truly delicious food. Read more

UPDATED: We went back to Wecome Market Hall for their incredible pizza and 2 side salads and were told they no longer serve side... salads and we'd need to chose a salad from the menu (this was after the waitress asked the kitchen). Three weeks ago, therestaurant responded to my original review and told me that they will do side salads. We left and I am changing the rating from4 to 2 stars. (The 2 stars are there only because the pizza is so good but pizza is not a complete meal for us.) We will not beback. ORIGINAL REVIEW FOR PIZZA ONLY: This was one of the best brick oven pizzas we have ever had. We consider ourselves "brickoven pizza snobs" and this was an incredible pizza. The tomatoes were the star and so flavorful. The crust was thin and cookedjust right with lightly burnt bubbles. We also had local brewery beer on tab (Blacktooth Amber Ale). The only reason forremoving a star from our rating was the lack of a dinner salad to accompany the pizza. (The 2 salads offered on the menu didn'thit the mark.) Read more

I recently had a large group dinner reservations here. They accommodated my large party easily, great communication, even moved... us inside for a quick dinner table transition when the weather hit. Quick on gettin us our meals, and wonderful drinks! Wethoroughly enjoyed ourselves and will be back. Thank you! Read more

Came for dinner & the live music. Dinner was very good & music was GREAT! I had the prosciutto & fig pizza. It was delicious. My... one suggestion to the kitchen?try adding rocket. Had it this way somewhere before -delicious! Oh & service was great! Read more

I can not say enough fabulous things about Market Hall. The atmosphere is fun, unique and immaculately clean. The staff is... spectacular and I just adore Alissa! She is definitely one of the main reasons I go there. She takes amazing care of me and anygroup events I am a part of. Alissa always makes me fee like a celebrity! :) Now we cannot forget about the food and theamazing Chef Travis! We have many group events there and he goes above and beyond on taking care of us. And the food oh my howamazing! Just had shrimp last night that was to die for! Travis has not disappointed in any meal I have had yet! I highlyrecommend Welcome Market Hall!!! Read more

I walked out of Sheridan and into New York! This spot is world class. Atmosphere is empeccable and bright. Colorful and... refreshing bar. My service was spot on. This establishment is out of it's element. Very impressive. Read more

I would love to love this place, it has fantastic atmosphere, great food but the service is very subpar. I expect this now post... COVID, customer service died more than anything. Great concept restaurant. Read more