Reviews for Andy's Frozen Custard in Sheridan, CO
How have I never rated this place?? Been coming here for years. Great custard. I grew up with a Sheridan?s nearby and these... guys do it so much better. Recommend everything, from the sodas, malts, concretes, jackhammers - all great. Never adisappointment Read more
Tasty but it was mostly fruit, almost no custard. Maybe we ordered the wrong thing but it was a bit disappointing.
Worst andys ever. Had a coupon to make one of our ice creams $1 and we ordered 2 things and it still came to $12 somehow. So the... girl definitely didnt use the coupon. And then one of the items was made wrong. Smh. Read more
Easily the best frozen custard around! It's so creamy and delicious and they are generous with the toppings and great customer... service every time. Everyone there is welcoming and nice, I'm glad it's my closest frozen custard place but I'd make the trek ifit wasn't. My all time fav, jackhammer with cheesecake, chocolate chips and a fudge filling, it's soooo good! Read more
Great place for custard. (Ice cream with egg added) Plenty of flavors. I like the banana split. Fresh bananas used. ???? Lots of... blinking lights outside and unique decor inside. Casual outdoor landscaping. (I'd suggest a couple of waste receptacles) Read more
I'm not usually one to stop for ice cream but as a last minute desert idea for my husband's birthday we pulled in and easily... found parking. We went inside to no line, a spotless interior, an easy to understand menu with a wide variety of options and ourgroup of 4 were in and out in under 10 minutes. I appreciated that the friendly employees were wearing masks while theysimultaneously helped us and the drive thru customers. We thoroughly enjoyed our dessert (I got a Butter Pecan Concrete turnedinto a Jackhammer with a delicious hot fudge center) and will gladly be back again soon. This would be a perfect place to stopat after the kiddos baseball game or after a movie at the near by theater. Can't wait to go back! Read more
Love Andy's Frozen Custard! The employees are nice and courteous, plus you don't have to wait a long time even if there is a... line. Read more
Great place for a treat! This area is amazing for a meal and some tasty custard. Will come back again