Reviews for The Islander in Shelter Island, NY
Food was great the service was lacking I asked for a plate never got had to go inside to ask for service left us waiting for... over 30 mins Read more
I literally have never written a restaurant review in my life, but felt compelled to do so after this experience. The restaurant... was almost empty when we came in, we ordered and our food took more than 30 minutes. When it finally came, my ?lightly fried?crab cakes were fried until black and flavorless. The mashed potatoes and broccoli literally tasted like nothing. Worst of all,my 2 year olds well done hamburger came out nearly raw. When we sent it back, it was taking so long that we told them to justforget it. I cannot believe what a bad meal this was. Read more
had a nice BBQ burger and fries ???? ????
Great place to bring a family, very cozy. Service has always been great never an issue.
Good food but very slow service. Not appraised of any problems
This place is a delight. The decor is charming and bright and the menu is excellent. We had omelettes and pancakes and our... little one had chicken nuggets and fries. The salads looked super fresh and big, and the burgers did as well. Friendly serviceand conveniently located in the middle of the island. We will definitely be back. Go here with family, friends, or even alone.Many people got take out while we were there too. Read more
Good variety. Quick moving. Cash only. The regulars keep their mugs hanging below the specials board. Many different local beers... available. I liked the pancakes and sausage. Read more
Burger and fries were great, definitely would recommend the fried pickles!!! Waitress was very nice and attentive. We waited for... the food a bit but that was the only negative Read more