Reviews for Center Cut in Shelbyville, IN
Steaks were over cooked from what we asked for, mashed potatoes were very clumpy, and waitress only asked us for one beverage.... Waitress didn't know what beverages the bar offered. Read more
Ordered meatloaf with mashed potatoes and salad. We requested it to go because we was in a hurry. No ranch dressing for the... salad, pretty sure the mashed potatoes are instant, and the meatloaf was somewhat mushy. My friends ny strip was supposed to bemedium rare and was much closer to medium. He ordered the mushrooms and toppings which was left off. We also ordered lobster Macand cheese that they forgot to put in the bag. Used the $100 celebration dinner otherwise I would be hot about having to pay forthat. It was comparable to Manns grille. Read more
The service was impeccable! The ribeye was tender, juicy and perfectly cooked, however the lamp chop was tough, chewy and dry.... Bit of a disappointment for the price. Won't be getting that again. The drinks were great as well and again, our server wasphenomenal! I will return but I'll be sure to get a steak next time. Read more
Located within Indiana Grand Casino, this steakhouse has delicious lamb chops and filet mignon with all the sides you could ever... want! The food, expectedly, did take about 30-45 minutes to come to the table which our awesome waitress warned us about whenordering the medium rare lamb chops (average cooking time she said)! Our experience was awesome and albeit on the pricier end,we?ll definitely find a reason to be back for more. Read more
EDIT- I previously rated Center Cut five stars, but upon my most recent visit on January 18, 2020, I was EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED!... No more nice selection of bread with three different spreads served on a Himalayan salt block. They now bring you some breadthat tastes like it was purchased off of the week old clearance section at the supermarket with a very bland spread...JUST ONESPREAD. My Cesar's salad was just a couple of purple and green leaves, with a dressing that lacked flavor. I ordered the filet,and requested a medium cook. It came out BLACKENED with a brown center. WAY OVERCOOKED! We also ordered a lobster mac andcheese. It came out lukewarm, and the lobster bits in it were overcooked and rubbery. I never thought I'd be so extremelydisappointed in any of Center Cut's offerings. Ever since Caesar's took over, they've made an effort to try and make even MOREmoney from the casino. The quality of the steakhouse is now even less than what I would expect from a place this nice. TexasRoadhouse is even better than Center Cut now. You'd think they would have let a good thing stand, but I guess greed got the bestof management, which I don't understand. They are making money hand over fist with the new gambling options, and still wantmore. For the amount of money I spent, I deserve better than what some chain can offer. I was going to bring my concerns toEric, the manager at the time of my visit. He is an excellent manager and use to run a tight ship. It's not his fault for thisplace to have gone downhill. I Will not spend anymore of my money here, and I'd advise to seek somewhere to eat before cominghere to gamble. The other food options are dismal at best. I will leave my original review below, so you can compare. CenterCut never disappoints! I went for my birthday dinner with my wife, and everything was delightful. The service is alwayssuperior, as is the food. I had a NY strip, with mashed potatoes and lobster mac and cheese. The bread plate always Read more
Place is fire, food is great! Check put my pictures!! Atmosphere is nice, light jazz piano in the background, lighting accents... are very modern yet cozy. Read more
Our steaks and dessert were delicious, as they always are. I would have given a 5 star but our service was not up to par... tonight. Read more
We visited last night 6/4/22 and ordered wine, crab cakes, side salads, 2 filets, and 1 ribeye. The filets came out as small... medallion hockey pucks. We ordered our temperature medium and medium rare and the steaks came out well done. No big deal, tryagain, however, it took them 40 minutes to get our new steaks out. Should have been maybe 3-5 minutes per side. We ended uptaking it home at this point we were unhappy and nobody cared to ask how our evening was. Just gave us our bill. Stay away.This place is not a steak house. Read more