Reviews for Cagney's Pizza King in Shelbyville, IN
One of our favorite pizza places in town. Great specials and a classic style and flavor! Great quality ingredients. This is old... school pizza at its finest! Read more
Something has changed recently with the pizza. Consistently the last few times we have ordered the pizza has been lacking the... salt that is on the dough. Hopefully this is just an oversight and not a recipe change as it leaves the pizza missing that itfactor Read more
Great pizza as always! One of my favorite local restaurants for my favorite ground pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza. Always... thin crust, crispy and tasty! Dining in margaritas are a must! Read more
Always a great place to eat. Friendly staff, great food, clean atmosphere, and the prices are reasonable. Surprisingly have a... great burrito for being a pizza place. Read more
Horrible. The service was awfull. Too much conversation about Florida trip with bartender and drunk lady at the bar who couldn't... stop using the F word every other word. Granted I've heard it before and have used it myself. But come on when you want to outto dinner you'd like to have a nice experience without the drama. Bobby still gave her $20 tip that she didn't earn. She onlychecked on us when she brought us the check. Not happy. But felt you needed to know. Read more
We ordered the Taco Pizza and it was Amazing! We are staying at Hotel Comfort Inn and they recommended them and we are so happy... we ordered ! Great Customer service we ordered cheese sausage pizza and chicken wings everything was delivered hot and Great! Would Recommend to all out of Towner's for sure ! From , Our Chicago Family ! Read more
The food was decent. The person handling the phones not so much. I was told 15-20 minutes is when my food would be ready. I got... there 25 minutes after I ordered. My food wasn't ready and when I asked why i was told 20 minutes instead of the actual time itwould be, the woman was very snarky and explained that at least it would be cold, and they are slammed so... I would get someoneelse on the phone instead of this older woman who clearly has no patience for a customers question. All I got was 2 burritos. Read more
Stopped by here as we were traveling through.. this is not your ordinary Indiana Pizza King... It is far superior... They have a... full menu with pizza of course but also pasta dishes and pasta salads and homemade soups..... It's in a unique older buildingwith interesting light fixtures..... The waitress was fantastic and the food was hot, fresh and delicious! Read more