Reviews for Peabody's Pizza Company in Sheboygan, WI
My favorite pizza place in all of sheboygan. Peabody's has the most consistently good taco and blt pizza in sheboygan. My... children also enjoy the various pastas very much. Read more
First, I'm from New England where real pizza is made. So, cheese heads, pay attention! This is probably one of the best and... closest thing to east coast pizza I've ever had in Wisconsin. This mini pizza was delicious, and a perfect size for a husky guylike me on a diet (after I already ate some chicken fried rice from the farmer's market... honestly I just wantedpizza). Excellent sauce to cheese to crust ratio. Caution: the "spicy" sausage isn't spicey by east coast standards, so i wasboth let down and happy that I wouldn't be coughing and trying to clear my throat going back to work. There wasnt any cheddarcheese (pizza should never come with cheddar... so they know something!), and I don't understand why green peppers are sopopular instead of red peppers. Oh well. This Peobody's special was packed with flavor, cooked fast (12 minutes when I was told15), and very affordable. I'd give it 4 stars, but the guy was friendly and this is Wisconsin, so it gets 5. But my taste budsare now salivating for the reviews of their taco pizza. I'll be back! Read more
Ordered several pizzas for a family get together. Upon opening the first pizza box, a piece of black hair was found in the... cheese/sauce. Pizza was not touched due to findings and left a negative impression. Contacted establishment the next day toinform them of findings. No apology extended. Will not patronize Peabody?s any more due to lack of apology. Situations happen,it?s how you respond or not respond to them that keeps loyal customers coming back. Read more
Absolutely delicious! Amazing prices for the amount of food you get. Will definitely come back whenever we are in town!! Oh and... the nachos are wonderful!! Read more
As a new member of Sheboygan I got this recommendation to visit Peabody's from a friend and I called tonight and this restaurant... is the only place where they personally make a small personal pizza! I will not go to Pizza Hut or some other chain, I wanted togo to an authentic pizza place and PeaBody's is the place! Perfect combination of crust, sauce and toppings too (I got sausage,mushroom and onion), not too much of any ingredient. Absolutely exquisite customer service as well! Read more
Don't let the storefront fool you. What they lack in seating (there is none...it's takeout only) and pretty colors they make up... in the most amazing Taco Pizza in town. Been going for years and it's always a hit in our household. Restaurant.com has certsfor them, as well as their weekly coupons, so if you're on a budget you'll find no issue making their pizzas cheaper than thecompetitors...which they still taste better than. From what I understand, they used to be partners running Pit Stop - butsplit. Peabody's seem to have improved on the original recipe, as I've had them side by side and it's superior to all others intown. Oh, don't sleep on the BLT pizza either. So tasty. Read more
Pretty disappointed. The veggie pizza was bland and a bit dry. A parmesan shaker at the counter would go a long way. I ordered... the 10 inch pizza over the 7-in because I wanted something leftover. Turns out that I got a barely 8.5 inch pizza and was stilla bit hungry. Nothing special here at this hole-in-the-wall and I wish I had gone to Toppers just a few block away instead. Read more
Very good pizza and nice people. This is only takeout and delivery but there's a nice seating area across the street where you... can eat the pizza. Read more