Reviews for Nicky's Pizza in Sheboygan, WI
We ordered subs. They were great. Yummy pizza's too. Very affordable.
Ordered yesterday.. Pizza was burnt I had one piece and immediately got sick ???? w diaharea ....food has gone downhill won't be... wasting time giving chances anymore not worth it!!!!!! Used to be best In town now it's worst!!!! Read more
8/25/2022 - We we're visiting Sheboygan and decided to eat at Nicky's. I had Kentucky Bourbon Wings, and my husband had... Spaghetti Limone w/mushrooms. I'd rate the wings an 8; they needed a bit more seasoning, but very tasty. My husband says herates the spaghetti dish a 7; he didn't taste any lemon and needed more seasoning, and he didn't care for the garlic bread. Read more
Rotten lettuce in our salads, the waitress was inexperienced and had 2 noisy kids in the booth next to ours with a loud cell... phone for entertainment. Service was slow and the pizza had huge chunks of onion and large clusters of black olives instead ofbeing evenly spread out. It seems like quality and consistency are no longer priorities. We won't be going back. Read more
I ordered through DoorDash and didn?t get my calzone. They said they gave it to the kid, and I have to talk to DoorDash. He said... he gave me my food. He?s probably eating it now but I found it to be poor customer service not to allow me to pick up a newcalzone. Read more
Love this place! It?s a great little hole in the wall with impeccable service and really tasty food! The Holy Moly Mushroom... pizza is so damn good! And the fried cheese curds are like crack!!! Read more
I was in town on business and mapped out local pizza places. I don?t consider myself an expert, but I?ve eaten pizza in lots of... places. The crust was crunchy , the toppings were generous, the sauce was a perfect compliment and not overwhelming, and theservice was quick and considerate. And a pro move...I took this to go and they put plastic over the cheese to prevent stickingto the paper. Nice touch. I?d recommend stopping if you?re in the area. Only downside was finding the parking in the rain andsnow. Read more
Very upsetting when you have a pizza delivered and out of the first bite you feel a Sharp crunchy something in your mouth when I... spit out the pizza in my hand I discovered a small coiled metal peice that I was chewing on that came from the pizza thankfullyI didn't swallow it!! We return the pizza and put the metal peice in a sandwich bag and we were refunded our money back theyapologize and said it must of came from the dishwasher to that was like wow.. Read more