Reviews for Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros in Selden, NY
Found a bone in my chicken mcnugget. I don't think this is the particular restaurants fault. But I guess that's what you get... with their processed food. Read more
We usually go here on Wednesday's to buy pizza and take it home. The guys behind the counter has akways been awesome. The pizza... has always been delicious, hot and full topping of Sausage. The price is also extremely competitive to the pizza places around.I can honestly say after going here for many years you are not going to find a better Italian restaurant. Read more
When you wanna SPLURGE and spend the extra $10 instead of cooking??. I have never been to Selden pizza only spoke with and... ordered via phone. No hold, no price gouging & will make what u want upon request?.., even 30min to close. Very humble and fornow??.???? My #1. O btw, cheese pie perfectly proportioned ???? Read more
UPDATE! Just came here again tonight Friday Aug19th. Asked for 1 lamb gyro loght lettuce, no onions, extra sauce on the... side. Only thing they got right was the lamb gryro. They fked up on the lettuce, no onions and extra sauce. Guess you cant relyon anyone for anything these days. #covid brain. Came here a few times and never had an issue. I always order the LambGyro. Tonight I ordered a Lamb Gryo platter, got home and opened it up. It was literally like a Gyro Salad or something. I HATEsalad. The Gyro wasn't even put together and the pita bread was wrapper separately. The meat was seperated... And the Fettacheese and veggies/ tomatoes were mixed together on the side along with the French frys. Kinda weird and its not what I askedfor. Idk if they miss understood me or it was pure lazyness but never again. Read more
One of the best Pizza places around!! Very reasonable prices, always consistent! Even my 90 yr old Italian mom says so!! ????
My sister ordered an Italian hero for Easter lunch and specifically said no dressing on it. When my brother in law went to get... it he asked where was the mayo on the side and they said that mayo doesn't go with an Italian hero but when my sister opened itit had mayo on it. The guy that was there gave her an attitude and told her to return it for her money back but she had guestarriving soon. He never apologized. So she went the day after Easter to speak with the owner, Max, and he said that mayo is nota dressing and that if she didn't want mayo on it she should have specifically said no mayo. He never apologized and even gaveher an attitude. She wasn't asking for her money back, she just wanted an acknowledgement of their mistake and a heartfeltapology. Read more
Ordered a gluten free pizza with olives, requested "well done". 1-Didn't get the olives. 2-It was not cooked enough. The very... outer edges were light brown, but the rest of the pizza was not cooked in any way. The underside was completely white, and thewhole pizza was completely mushy and doughy. Had a slice and felt sick the rest of the night. Very disappointing especiallyafter asking for it to be well done. The only postive outcome was that I lost my appetite and didn't want to eat after that. Read more
I would recommend Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros to friends and family. Great food!