Reviews for Jerry's Pizza & Subs in South Seaside Park, NJ
Stopped in at Jerry?s after Island Beach State Park, I had an awesome burger, the wife had an amazing cheesesteak, and we... shared, what we both said, was the best fries we ever had Read more
Service, no rating as we did takeout. Food. The pizza was great. The salad was great as well. The sandwich was on a roll. We... ordered a chicken parm sub. While the order taker explained that they had no sub rolls, the sandwich we received was verysmall. This was also true for the salad especially because we ordered a large salad. Prices. $40 for single sized portions. Definitely overpriced based on the portion sizes. Result. No service, very undersized portions and high prices rates threestars. Sorry about this as the food was generally speaking very good. Read more
Excellent all around spot, especially for pizza. We love their Jersey devil specialty pizza with the hot cherry peppers, which... isn?t on the menu but seems to always be available. Good sandwiches and apps too. Read more
Had a wonderful day at the beach ruined by the people who own this establishment. I walked in with a few of my friends prepared... to spend $14 plus on sandwiches to be given dirty looks and ignored. No hello, No welcome, no how are you. We pick up the menusand kindly ask if it is possible to customize sandwiches just to receive an extremely rude response from the elderly womanworking the counter. Beware of her she is horrible. What kind of sandwich shop doesn?t allow paying customers to make their ownsandwich?? We immediately left because we felt so attacked. NEVER eat here. Read more
Subs are large and loaded. My favorite is their grilled chicken caprese. A little pricey, but as is everything around.... Definitely the best subs in seaside park. Quick service and turn around if you call ahead to place an order. Read more
First time ordering from here and it won't be the last! I got a house salad w grilled chicken and it didn't disappoint! Prices... are also great! Great food @ a reasonable price is hard to find. Read more
One of my favorite spots on the island. I eat there several times a week. Outstanding pizza. I love their cheesesteaks and the... chicken parmigiana is great. I just wish they served regular spaghetti not only Angel hair as an option. Breakfast, lunch &dinner. It's all solid. ????? Read more
September 27, 2022 edit: best Stromboli I?ve ever eaten in my entire life. Had it custom ordered because the kind Ukrainian... gentleman at the register said I could. I probably should?ve put a shirt on, but I love that you can walk into these places inswimwear and it?s no problem. I decided upon a chicken-bacon-ranch-with mushroom Stromboli. I call it: The Chillaxin! And nowthat I know the owners are Deadheads because of the Terrapin compass inside, I love this establishment even more. Very gratefulto you all!! ?????????????????????? Read more