Reviews for Gino's of Seaford in Seaford, NY

Best regular slice of pizza on Long Island hands down bar none. Specialty slices great also and the chicken Parmesan... unbelievable. Everyone super friendly and helpful. Highly recommend this place! Read more

Came in with the family for some slices around dinner time and as always the pizza was great, a little pricy but worth it, and... the kid behind the counter was a pleasure! Read more

I?m new to the area and stopped in for a pie. Had a slice while I was waiting. I have to say best pizza I?ve had since I moved... here. Can?t wait to come in with my friends for dinner. Keep up the great work You can sit down or take out. So much to choosefrom on the menu. Read more

I had 2 different types of slices from different pies and something is a bit off with the pizza dough with both the chew and the... flavor. The other ingredients were great though. Read more

Great food. A little pricey but everything is nowadays with all the sheet going on in the world/politics. Love their Spinach... Broccoli Pinwheels (especially if they make them fresh for you). I definetly recommend. Read more

I always use the term " what'd I do break a window when I walked in" when I receive a Bill that is outrageous. Gino's has to... recognize that their prices are usurious and every slice or pie or meal is not supposed to break the bank. Over $13 for 3different slices of pizza, over $4 for a grandma slice is as close to theft without a gun that you can get. Make them bigger andjustify your cost per slice but don't give me what you did and say it's fair because it isn't and it will never be. The tasteof the pizza was good, but it was nothing compared to the taste of paying for PIZZA Read more

They have a lot of specialty slices that are great, but their pepperoni pie is easily one of the best in the area. A lot of... pizzerias are obsessed with the crazy specialty pies now, and don?t perfect their basic classic slices, but not thisestablishment. They use small pepperoni cups instead of big pepperoni slices. I?d ask for it a little more well done in thefuture but it?s an otherwise perfect pepperoni slice. The vodka sauce rice balls are excellent as well. Highly recommend. Read more

Lovee this place. The loaded garlic knots are my favorite. Their Margarita slice is my favorite and the men at the counter are... very nice. Read more