Reviews for Brooklyn Square Pizza in Seaford, NY
We ordered a Sicilian pizza and I've never in all my life got it the way I got it. Crust, cheese and sauce. So messy! Other... pizza restaurants make the Sicilians crust, sauce and cheese. Terrible. Just terrible. Read more
The square pie is very delicious. The sauce on top has just the right amount of sweetness to it and there is not and... overwhelming amount of cheese. Read more
So disappointed tonight ordered a brooklyn square pie, ask the girl to please make sure it is a fresh pie. Should have looked... in the box it had to be reheated pie once again. The sauce was dry on the pizza and it was cold. Ordered the pizza at 5:50pmit was waiting for me on the counter at 6:05 dry and cold. I should have realized! Chicken wrap was good and buffalo slice wasgood. Shame on you! Fooled me twice shame on me Read more
I don't usually do reviews, but this place was so good, I had to. This was our first time eating from there. We ordered later in... the evening and usually late night orders aren't given the same love, but this place produced some awesome food despite the latehour. The bbq ranch pizza was literally the best we've had. I got the penne al vodka and it was delightful, I could not believeit was take-out. Garlic knots were amazing, and the calzone was *chef's kiss* We will definitely be coming back here. 10/10definitely recommend! Read more
Hands down the best pizza you will find in all of Long Island. The Grandma slice is my favorite but they may have the best... meatballs ever. I just moved to Seaford and come here regularly. Don?t take my word, try them once for yourself and you?ll behooked Read more
This is the best pizza! Sweet tomato sauce on top of thin layer of fresh mozzarella cheese. No garlic, onions or dried spices.... Very light and refreshing. Not your typical Sicilian slice. May not be for everyone but I love it. Read more
Excellent authentic N.Y. style pizza with sesame crust! The garlic knots are delicious and not too doughy!
Great customer service by jack Ava and Fernando