Reviews for The Old Mill Pizzeria & Restaurant in Sciota, PA
Just got a large pepperoni pie to go. Great every time!!
I was truly pleasantly surprised by this place, and I had a wonderful slice of grandma pizza when I stopped by one day after... working a job in the area. Typically I don?t think of Stroudsburg as an area in which I can get good quality pizza, but thislittle place Is worth a visit. Don?t be put off if there is no other cars in the parking lot. It reflects the ZIP Code not thefood for sure. I don?t typically try places where I don?t see other diners, but I gave this place a chance, and I?m glad I did.The grandma pie as I said was delicious, they add small drizzles of pesto, a slight variation from most. But I thought it tastedgreat! The crust was not too thick, slight crunch to it, cheese melted on top nicely, And the sauce was hearty and exactly howgrandma sauce should taste. I could tell it was fresh as well, it wasn?t prior day pizza or anything. The owners there areextremely nice, I chatted with them for a couple minutes. They obviously care about their customers, and I truly respect theproduct they put out what with the challenges having a business in that area. Kudos to you! Also, the place is super clean andthe atmosphere is lovely. I just thought they deserved a shout out! Read more
I ordered the shrimp scampi, only ended up eating two shrimp and within an hour my stomach was hurting me and then I began... throwing up the shrimp scampi. I?m disappointed because I used to love this place but now I will not be returning. How I feelright now is not worth coming back and my husband agrees. Read more
Went and ordered a pepperoni pizza for dinner. It was one of the best pizzas that we had in a long time. I definitely would... recommend eating at Old Mill Pizza. Read more
5 Stars for their cheese steaks, it's not just a pizza joint they also have gyros. You can get it to go or dine in.
Now, I?m really never one to complain but you can?t up your prices on your customers and then put less toppings? i.e. myself who... orders from here weekly? I paid 36 dollars for a small CBR pizza and a large plain pie.. I did call, and a new pizza to be maidwas offered but that isn?t an option for me as I work overnights and I need to get ready, so I don?t have the time to wait foranother pizza to be made? I feel bad leaving this but, truly, I?m disappointed, I wasn?t offered any other solution? I won?t bereturning. Read more
Had a house full of kids. Kids love pizza...any kind of pizza. The basic plain, Pepperoni, and meat lovers were fantastic! But... let me tell you about the pie ordered for the adults.... CBR (chicken ???? bacon ???? ranch) in a stuffed pizza. How was it?they nailed it. Chiken was tender, bacon was flavorful, and the amount of cheese was perfect. Thanks to Old Mill Pizza formaking this one off pizza! Read more
For over twenty years one of our favorites Best Stromboli, best Greek salad! Staff all pleasant and the owner Izzi is fantastic