Reviews for Patellini's Pizza in Sarasota, FL
My co-workers and I were walking down the street and found a NY pizza place. I have lived in NY and unfortunately this did NOT... hit the spot. In my option a homemade thin crust is where it is at when you say NY. It was good for pizza, just not the best.Maybe it was just a off day? Read more
I'm working down town a block away from this place. The pizza is OK at best (maybe good if you're drunk down town). I've been... there 3 times. The 1st time had pizza with no problems. They 2nd time I had a meatball sub. That wasn't all that good and itshould have as long as it took to make. The 3rd and last time I'll be there. I had pizza again that took 15 minutes to heat up 2slices (it was not busy by any stretch). So if you don't mind waiting for marginal food, This is the place for you! Read more
I have never had a pie taste so much like absolutely nothing at all. I don't believe this restaurant actually owns... seasonings. Garlic bread was good tho, only reason it doesn't get negative one stars. Read more
Not just the best pizza in Sarasota or Florida or the US....best pizza in the world. I've been eating it for 20 years always... consistently awesome. 5 stars. Read more
The GF pizza crust is delicious. The food was very fresh tasty.
Great NY Pizza. I'm from NY and recently moved here. This place is being added to my list of places to eat at. Nice outdoor... seating area too, if you want. Read more
Patellini's Pizza: Through Grub Hub During our stay in Sarasota, we decided to order some pizza to the hotel room as we settled... in. We ordered online through the Palletini website that was associated with Grub Hub. At first we had trouble locating aPepperoni pizza, but finally figured out we could do a Cheese pizza and Add Pepperonis (+$1.75), so that is what we did. Weordered that, 2 garlic knots, Baked Ziti Pasta, and extra marinara ($.75) and ranch ($.75). Upon completing the order, we wereinformed that it would be 30-45 minutes and the driver would contact us on the way. After 40 minutes we got a call from thefront lobby that our food was dropped off in the lobby, no notification from the driver. Once I got the food up to the room, werealized that the extra $1.50 in sauces had not been included. We also did not receive a pepperoni pizza like we had ordered,and the garlic knots were hard and cold. The best part of the meal was the Baked Ziti which was pretty basic. I would givethis place another try, but unfortunately cannot give it anywhere close to 5 out of 5. Read more
Day of christmas boat parade, they accommodated my party of 10. Pizza was huge and fantastic. 20 inch is massive! Some crusts... were a bit under cooked but over all great. We had ny cheese (5 star) Bacon and garlic (4 star bc crust was undercooked) Andpepperoni (5star) Read more