Reviews for New York Slice Company in Sarasota, FL
My first time ordering food and eating from this NY pizza joint. I ordered 2 pies and a supreme calzone, one cheese and one 3... topping. The crust was just right. I typically favor pizzas with toppings when ordering from chain pizza places but theircheese pizza was more flavorful than the pizza with 3 toppings. I wish the 3 toppings pizza would be just as flavorful. Thecalzone supreme was fine. The sauce it came with was delicious! I used it on my 3 toppings pizza and that gave it flavor it waslacking. Nevertheless, the pizzas were good and satisfied my cravings! Read more
worse experience...never go back. I always try to see the best of everything INCLUDING BAD EXPERIENCE...But Men never never have... being treated so bad. I when there may 14 2022 at 4:55 came in and saw some on the phone taking what I think was a dificultorder...and I understand I have to wait, but no one acknowledge me or no one with me. I work daily with people customer serviceit 100% important...after 15 minutes wait I approached the cashier are and guess NO ONE NO ONE say even Hi!...we just left andno one even say Sorry. I guess they are doing so so well that not need a other customer. worst ever....oooo and the pleace wasempty . I give one star but just becuase I can't give a -0. Read more
Great LOCAL pizza with friendly service. The deals and quality they have can not be beat by the chains. We like getting the 3... for Thursday deal and we add salad for the adults. One salad is enough for 2 to share. The twists are our favorite appetizer,but the stuffed mushrooms are amazing as well. Read more
Went to the Wendy's in their parking lot and they had drive through only so I tried these guys out. For the price I was very... pleased with what I received. Their 2 slice and a can of soda for $5 is probably the best deal in town. I'm from Boston so Ilike the up North style of pizza and this is it. Thin crispy crust with tasty chees and sauce. This isn't fine dining, it's a nofrills seating area but it's all you need for this. The service was excellent as well. This is now my new stop when I'm on thego. I highly recommend this place. Read more
Coming from New York this place really lives up to its name ! Crunchy crust good cheese and sauce distribution just really... tasty and a great special deal for 4.95 for two slices in a drink. Moving to Sarasota from New York I was looking for placeslike this . I'm happy I found it because it reminds me of there. Looking forward to trying other things on the menu to now Read more
The pizza is thin, has flavor but was supposed to be pepperoni but with very little pepperoni on the slices under the cheese.... They have a great deal for two slices but not enough toppings. Read more
Being from Jersey, good pizza is hard to find down here. This pizza hit the mark. Good quality cheese, crispy crust, and good... sauce. Hand tossed to order. Also had the sausage stuffed mushrooms. Very tasty and cheesy. Friendly staff. Will be going back. Read more
My family and I love this place. Great weekly specials, and family friendly atmosphere. The staff wear masks and take care of... the place, it?s very clean. I highly recommend this establishment! Great Customer Service. Read more