Reviews for Michelangelo Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant in Sarasota, FL

The food was incredible ????. The server was amazing. Unfortunately, the take-outs trumped the diners. My meal came out... first (salad and meatballs). It took about another hour before my husband's food came out (Slice of pizza and a calzone). Although apologetic, it left us each eating alone while the other waited. They should have made some provision for the obviousinconvenience, but did not. Don't let this stop you from enjoying the fabulous menu items. I have since ordered pickup twiceand always have been 100% satiated. Read more

First, they "were out of the small pie", so they upped me without asking, to a large (because they had that) at a cost of $12... extra. Then, the "bacon" was lumps of what smelled like dog food. "Bacon product"? Maybe... But NOT BACON! Finally, they choseto replace my jalapenos with green peppers. I don't throw out pizza, but I threw most of this one. Don't mess with my bacon! Read more

Highly recommend! My favorite pizzeria. The food is amazing and the closest I've found to "real" NY pizza. Also they're very... family friendly and accommodating to my son with autism who usually struggles to dine in at restaurants. Very awesome and kindstaff. Read more

Our office typically orders the Wednesday hero special(s) and it doesn't disappoint. The customer service over the phone and in... person is exceptional!! One of the owners helped me to car and he was also a delight. 10/10 highly recommend. Read more

Their pizza is top notch! I think the difference is the cheese they use. Order on Monday-Wednesday and ask for the special which... is a medium sized pizza for $8 you can then add toppings for a couple dollars more. Always consistent and on time! Love theconvenience of ordering online ahead of time too! Read more

Looking for NY style pizza? This is the place!!! Legit the best tasting pizza in Sarasota hands down. ????Cannoli was also... delicious. Both the pizza & cannoli brought me back to NY ?? Massive gratitude to the owner & chefs! PERFECTO!!! Read more

We love Michelangelo?s usually as the food and service are generally outstanding. This trip was completely different. To start... with it was uncomfortably hot in there like the AC was down and they had the back door of the restaurant propped open whichallowed flies to be everywhere. Their dining area was nowhere near busy but they were slow. When we finally got our food nothingwas hot, just warm. Our server never came to check on us so we just ate our dinner because it wasn?t terrible just not hot. Iwas surprised by the number of people working but the service was slow and the food was subpar. We will be back since we usuallyhave excellent food and service. Hopefully tonight was just an off night. Read more

Michelangelo?s was hopping on a Saturday night! The pizza was good, not great. The cheese was melted but not bubbly or golden.... The sauce was good. The garlic knots were the standout of the meal! Will I go back again, probably not. I think there are betteroptions. But it was good and staff were responsive. Read more