Reviews for Mellie's New York Deli SRQ (located inside Rally's/Shell) in Sarasota, FL

This place is absolutely pathetic. Ordered salad and club sandwich, they were out of cucumber for salad , toaster was broke.... This what you do and you do it terrible, you shouldn't be in business. The young man working there was trying his Best Read more

The food is amazing but customer service can use some improvement.

ordered on door dash. Fresh and Great! Definitely a new go to place.

Biggest pizza slices I've ever seen. Buffet style with tots and fries. Everyday day breakfast and lunch is different and made... fresh right in front of you if you like. Definently check em out, girls are sooo friendly!! Read more

My experience was great I enjoyed the food and service the manager Danielle was very polite I will be visiting again ????

I had a previous bad experience with Mellies, but it turns out that my UberEats driver was a no-show not once, but twice, on the... same order! I stopped by in person a few days later to try the food. The Sarasota location is within a gas station. I orderedthe potato balls and loved them. They use Boars Head meats. The guy running it that day was friendly. I've never been to aauthentic NY deli, but this place will have me returning for the potato balls. Read more

Great food! I stop here almost every morning to get a grab and go lunch for work! I will definitely reccomend this place to... everyone I know! Read more

Great place I will eat here every morning