Reviews for Great American Cookies in Sarasota, FL

Great cookies and very delicious! Friendly staff. Don't listen to Victoria Singer, you can tell she is affiliated with another... cookie company. Read her other reviews. Read more

never personally bought these cookies, but my friend brought me some to try, they were DISGUSTING!!! we were throwing up in the... bathroom 2 minutes later. very sweet and not flavorful. go to clarabell cookies if u want some delicious, perfectly madecookies!! Read more

They have amazing cookies with so much variety! There cookies are amazing and I recommend anyone to try one out!

We did not receive the item we ordered. We have been coming here for years and this is by far the worst cookie we received. The... whole thing was not fully iced, as requested. As well as there was no color on the happy birthday. We called and the lady wasnot friendly until the end. It was frustrating to receive this for a special birthday. Read more

Delicious cookie cake for a birthday celebration, they even wrote us a card!

The cookies are fresh and delicious!! I love the custom decorated cookies. Laura did a great job decorating a cookie for our... bridal shower at work. Read more

Cookies were fairly priced, but you could tell they weren't freshly baked in a few hours. The staff was friendly and ordering... and paying was simple and quick. They have good location next to Coldstone creamery at UTC on 2nd floor. Read more

They don't know how to design the art design you show them. Sloppy work. I had to scrape off what they designed and left no... design on it. Looked better then their art. Read more